Ristorante da Sergio in Norderney

It was super nice, the food was so delicious. I can only recommend it.

Very nice restaurant. I liked it a lot. The food was great and you can sometimes find something unusual. The restaurant is reserved again for the next visit to Norderney.

I always look forward to eating at Sergio's again. (Now 15 times) We always order a table a few weeks in advance. The food is very tasty and tasty. Unfortunately this time we had to wait a very long 11/2 hours for our food, about 4 couples who came after us got their food beforehand. When I asked when the food would come, I was put off and the waiter was very unfriendly. Despite the tip, there was no thank you and no apology. We celebrated our wedding there a few years ago, but we have never received such service. Too bad

Pizza was tasty, although I personally prefer a thicker base. And the knives....were a disaster and couldn't cut the pizza. Service very cheerful and friendly

The reception, ambience and food are good. If the tip isn't right, you'll be ignored straight away and you'll get the feeling that the quicker you leave the restaurant, the better. The behavior of the employees in the pizzeria is probably due to the flow of guests in such a tourist hotspot. Three stars!

The food is excellent - the price is higher, but you really get something for it. The service depends on the day - we have had really nice waiters, but we have also experienced people forgetting their food for over an hour, tables being in the last corner despite reservations weeks in advance and of course the arrogance that has been described here many times. Be it that you don't listen to well-founded criticism at all or don't even say thank you for a decent tip - in those moments you realize that you're in the tourist shed!

Extremely good. Would love to come back again, very friendly service. Great day card, keep it up.

The food is always really good but unfortunately we have often been disappointed by the service… There are too many good alternatives on the island for you to go there more often. Too bad

Ein derartig unfreundlicher und unverschämter Service, nahezu unbeschreiblich. Wir haben einen großen Tisch anlässlich eines Geburtstages für 16 Personen einige Wochen im Voraus bestellt. Um sicher zu gehen, dass unsere Reservierung am Abend nicht in Vergessenheit gerät, haben wir eigens mittags noch einmal nachgefragt und wurden gebeten, der Einfachheit halber vorab eine gemeinsame Vorspeise zu bestellen. Beim abendlichen Eintreffen unserer Gruppe sollten wir uns dann plötzlich auf 2 Tische aufteilen, die nicht einmal nebeneinander lagen. Unsere Irritation war entsprechend groß und wir baten höflich um die Korrektur der nicht nachgekommenen Reservierung. Mit einer unvorstellbaren Arroganz wies man unsere Bitte brüsk zurück und war nicht bereit, den gemeinsamen Tisch entsprechend zur Verfügung zu stellen bzw. behilflich zu sein. Auch im Verlauf des weiteren Abends wurden wir sehr unhöflich und herablassend bedient, wobei das Essen jedoch gut war. Für diesen bornierten Italiener zeigen unsere Daumen klar nach 👎🏻 O Tempora, o mores

Pride comes before a fall Such unfriendly and rude service, almost indescribable. We ordered a large table for a birthday for 16 people a few weeks in advance. In order to make sure that our reservation was not forgotten in the evening, we asked again at lunchtime and were asked to order a shared starter in advance for the sake of simplicity. When our group arrived in the evening, we were suddenly told to split up into two tables that weren't even next to each other. Our irritation was correspondingly great and we politely asked for the reservation to be corrected. With an unimaginable arrogance, they brusquely rejected our request and were not prepared to make the shared table available or to help. As the evening progressed, we were served very rudely and condescendingly, although the food was good. Our fingers are clearly pointing to this narrow-minded Italian 👎🏻 Oh tenses, oh mores

Perfect!! Marco the waiter was very dry but also humorous and perfect in his job!!! I would recommend it again and again!!!

Incredibly rich, delicious grill plate. Everything perfect. Therefore, understandably, table reservations are mandatory.

Unfortunately, we can now agree with some of the reviews: the lady of the house seems arrogant. We didn't have a reservation, so we parked on the side anyway. Then ordered: one of two drinks was forgotten, then came. Main course: one of two wrong. We had ordered pizza and never tartare. The second wine was then forgotten again. Honestly, this is really bad for a table of 2 people. Our food (salad and something like pizza) was okay for a snack, but didn't have much to do with Italy and the price level. Dessert, espresso, digestif were not offered. We won't be coming back again and would advise everyone to check out the numerous alternatives.

We had a wonderful evening with very good food and excellent service. Very nice, very polite and above all very attentive. Be sure to reserve!

Island Italian with lots of space, although it doesn't look that spacious from the outside. From the homemade ravioli to tagliatelle with truffles, appetizers to fall in love with, pizza of course, whole fish, prawns, fillet tips... We tried everything and everyone was full. More than that: it tastes absolutely Italian here, from the first leaf of lettuce to a really great crème brulee. Despite the large crowds (make a reservation!), the kitchen is really busy and has everything under control, also thanks to the attentive staff. 100% recommendation. Update: you can leave it like that even a year later. Prices on the island are usually 10-20% above the mainland level, but if you come to Norderney you have to take that into account.

We were four people in this modern and very nice restaurant. The kitchen didn't manage to serve the food at the same time. One meal was even completely forgotten. Based on the boss's reactions, such an incident appears to be unimportant. The spaghetti “Aglio i Olio” is rather below average for an Italian restaurant. On Norderney you don't seem to be particularly dependent on friendliness and quality.

Grill plate was a treat, rather too much, monkfish was also great. Cooked and served to perfection, the service was absolutely professional. Thanks! Update: today 4.1.25 Chewy fish and duck breast: perfect 6 stars! Thanks.

Spaghetti is not al dente but too soft, monkfish sometimes. Tough like a tendon. What was great was beef tartare. Otherwise, if you go to Italian restaurants, this is second rate.

As always, very good cuisine, great products and an excellent service team, especially the boss. Any time. Early reservation is essential!

Anyone who comes here can enjoy fine Italian cuisine. My friend had tagliatelle with venison ragout and I had the grilled plate. Both were very good. Since we wanted dessert, we decided not to have a starter. What passed us looked more than good. For dessert there was a cheesecake and a chocolate soufflé, which was also very tasty. Prices are high but still totally okay. If you want a good wine, this is the place for you. Staff very friendly and accommodating. Often comes by the table and asks if everything is OK, but in a non-intrusive way. We'll be back 5*

Were here several times during our vacation and both the food and the service were A1. Always a good place to go

We were greeted with a bit of a snooty attitude. The "lady" of the house is something better and she gives the impression that you have to be grateful to be able to eat here. Plus, we felt like we were bothering them. Doesn't matter. Welcome ticked off. Let's get to the service. Attentive, friendly and always trying hard. Sometimes with gaps in knowledge when implementing the order, but overall a very attentive impression. The quality of the food is not particularly outstanding. What I expect in an Italian restaurant was fulfilled. Not particularly bad but not great either. Just normal. What struck me negatively was that the service ended when the main course was cleared away. No question about a dessert or an espresso and/or a digestive. Since we really wanted it, but it wasn't offered, we made up for it at another location. Loss of sales approx. €30. Unfortunately, there was also a lot of farewell because the hotel receptionist preferred to chat with the service staff rather than say goodbye to guests. We basically had to go straight through the "staff group" but they moved to the side but didn't pay any attention to us. Maybe you can learn from criticism. Conclusion: If you expect something special, this is not the right place for you. An Italian restaurant that promises a lot but unfortunately delivers little. Everyone gets a second chance and I'll report back as soon as I'm there again.

Als Vorspeise gab es eine Kürbis Ingwer Suppe mit Flusskrebsen und Kürbiskernöl. -anschließend gab es frischen Thunfisch mit Linguine mit Kapern und Pistazien . Entenbrust auf frischem Rotkohl mit Kartoffelgratin und Orangensud . Dazu einen tollen Grauburgunder….. 👌

Extremely delicious. Top quality and super friendly service

Were here twice and were completely thrilled twice! Really cozy restaurant, nice and very attentive waiters and of course the most important thing: the food was great! Absolute recommendation: Monkfish fillet alla Sergio! A poem. Our dog was also very welcome! At this point I would like to send my warmest regards to the super nice boss. If we need a DJ soon, we'll get in touch ;-) We felt really comfortable with you! Definitely coming back!

The most decent food on the island. I’m picky with food but coming here never disappoints me. I love every single menu I tried, especially salmon tagliatelle and pepper steak. It’s perfectly cooked and seasoned by experienced chef. This is our most frequent place to come and really enjoy flawless food. Don’t forget to finish it with the marvelous chocolate soufflé. We’ve been here over 10 times and they really exceed our expectations every time. I can say this is one of the best restaurants in the whole Germany.

A nice place to dine/tasty/friendly/filling

Very friendly, attentive staff, very tasty food of very good quality, we would like to come back.

A slightly more upscale restaurant with a great selection of dishes that make it difficult to choose. The gluten-free Penne Frutti di Mare were excellent (no problems with celiac disease) and pizza can also be prepared gluten-free here. Very courteous service, we would love to come back!

Great restaurant, with friendly hosts. Food and drinks are of very good quality. There is a pleasant feel-good atmosphere in the restaurant. Hope to see you soon.

It was a really tasty meal, all the dishes we had were unbeatable.

A great restaurant with very friendly staff. We had a very tasty and excellent meal on two evenings, each with starter and dessert. It's a shame that there is no Da Sergio in our hometown, then we would be regular customers. We recommend the restaurant without reservation.

Sehr enttäuschend. Gerichte, die auf der Tafel im Restaurant als Spezialitäten angepriesen wurden, waren nicht verfügbar, Die Scampi vom Grill waren nicht gegrillt, sondern im Ofen gegart. Der Geschmack und die Konsistenz, fad und labberig. Die frittierten Sardinen waren ebenfalls nicht knusprig, sondern viel zu weich. Dies haben wir freundlich vorgetragen, als wir gefragt wurden, ob es uns geschmeckt hat. Darauf wurde weder mit einer Entschuldigung, noch sonst irgendwie reagiert. Meiner Meinung nach sehr unprofessionell und fast arrogant. Vielleicht besser nur eine Pizza bestellen. Die sah am Nachbartisch ok aus.

Ordered a salad with chicken breast strips. I got the starter salad, which my companion also had, with a pressed plate of poultry-like substance cut into strips. I get this thing from the hot air fryer when I'm in a hurry. The feel-good factor was also low for me. The waiters ran through the store with facial paralysis, as if they had just come from a mafia “customer meeting”. My companion's pizza was OK... nothing more. No revelation. You can get one of these on every corner. However, the ambience is quite nice. Not too bright light, quiet and you don't feel like you're at a train station.

Wir hatten uns auf einen schönen Abend mit leckerem italienischen Essen gefreut (wie schon ein Jahr zuvor). Leider war die Suppe nur lauwarm , die Pasta nicht al dente , das Gemüse ziemlich verkocht und die Soße nicht fein. Auch die Fischsuppe war etwas leblos. Dafür war der Wein gut . Der Service war dieses Mal ausbaufähig . Der Kellner hatte uns zwar nach Reklamation einen Kaffee oder Digestiv auf Kosten des Hauses angeboten. Da war das Thema für uns aber leider schon durch. Schade.

Perfect food, upscale atmosphere

Was on October 30th. with my husband at Da Sergio. It was a beautiful evening. The food was delicious except for the fact that my monkfish was completely overcooked. I told the waitress that it was a great dish, except for my fish. Unfortunately no one was interested. Therefore only 3 stars.

Hectic pace, time pressure and little appreciation for the guest expressed in particular through the behavior of the boss. Check-in like at a train station.

Wir waren direkt zweimal diesen Urlaub im Da Sergio essen und beide Male waren wir mehr als zufrieden. Wir hatten eine Vorspeisenplatte von der werde ich die nächste Zeit schwärmen. Wirklich außergewöhnlich. Eine tolle Auswahl und alles super frisch und lecker. Auch die Hauptgänge von Nudeln bis Pizza , Fisch bis Fleisch waren alle durchgängig erstklassig. Wir waren super überrascht, dass uns dieser Laden nicht eher aufgefallen ist und wir werden definitiv wiederkommen..

At 9:30 p.m. we had a seat and ate pizza, lasagna and tiramisu. Reception and service were very good and attentive. Lasagna and tiramisu were very tasty, 5 stars so far. The Quattro Stagioni pizza was topped with too much cheese and wasn't fully baked. This can be crispier and tastier. For this reason I deduct a point. Otherwise 5 stars. Thank you

Very attentive staff, really delicious food that came super quickly. We cannot understand the rating of “only” 4.3 stars. We would be happy to come back at any time, an absolute highlight!

The waiter was slightly overwhelmed and tried to blame his mistake on the guests. The food was better, but the price-performance ratio wasn't right.

No words needed. As always a 10/10!

Simply a great restaurant. The best Italian there is

Ate very well. Fresh sole. Super tasty fried potatoes. Delicious crème brulee. Good wine selection. Unfortunately poor champagne selection😡

Despite having celiac disease, we were able to eat there without any problems. The service was great, the pizzas were delicious and everything was nice and clean with no crumbs on the tables.

Wir hatten einen schönen Abend in diesem Restaurant. Vom exzellenten Service bis hin zum qualitativ gute Essen war alles einfach perfekt. Die Atmosphäre war sehr angenehm, und wir haben uns rundum wohlgefühlt. Besonders die sorgfältige Zubereitung der Gerichte hat uns beeindruckt. Wir kommen gerne wieder und können diesen Ort wärmstens empfehlen!

We were looking forward to a lovely evening. Unfortunately we were very disappointed with the food. The pizza I ordered came out wrong, which isn't a bad thing. But then a short time later the same pizza came again and the toppings I didn't order were simply removed (there were still leftovers on the pizza) and the pizza was cold. The other pizza was still almost raw. Unfortunately, both pizzas were still charged in full when payment was made. A concession would have been desirable.

I visited this restaurant with a few friends. We spent a very nice evening here together and had a lot of fun. The waiter was very friendly and gave us some very good recommendations regarding the starters and the main course. So I decided on the Dry Aged Tomahawk Steak with a friend. As a small starter we had bruschetta. To drink there was a Primitivo di Manduria, a very tasty Italian red wine. As we finished our appetizers, our tomahawk steak was served at the table. What a wonderful moment. The meat was very tasty and very tender. Our friends also highly praised the food and its taste. In the end it was a very nice and harmonious evening that we all obviously had a lot of fun with.

Courteous service, excellent food. We really enjoyed it again 👍

Chic restaurant. A large selection of food and drinks. I decided on a pizza, delicious. Price and service are right.

Delicious dishes. Great craft. Always my pleasure! Good espresso.

Simply a good Italian restaurant with a large selection, you can still get something to eat here even late.

Top shop, nice and attentive service, child-friendly and food was great. We'll be back!

I had a very tasty meal here. An early reservation is essential as the restaurant is particularly busy in the evenings.

Super nice location. In the middle of town

Great location. I don't have enough energy for five stars. Overall, definitely recommended,

Too loud, too dark, not well organized

A good address for Italian cuisine on Norderney

....the food could be a little less greasy. Otherwise everything was great.

The food was great, but the service was very poor. After the waiter changed, no request for a second drink or dessert. No waiter even came to make himself known. Grumpy service afterwards, even though it wasn't full. You convey your point of view - I don't care

Ordered food on site after a long day at the beach Very friendly reception with information about a 20 minute waiting time. After less than 20 minutes we received the food (2 × lasagne, tuna pizza and spaghetti aioli). The food was very tasty and is highly recommended. The welcome and service were also very friendly.

My companion had rump steak with “special fries” that looked very good, and it was. Unfortunately I ordered pizza. Looked good, but turned into a squishy rubber disc in no time, terrible. Since it wasn't edible, I ordered spaghetti with oil and garlic. They were aldente and also nicely seasoned. Afterwards grappa and espresso, neither of which is recommended. The grappa was quite a booze and the espresso was sour like a lemon.

Delicious Italian dishes that taste like they were skillfully “homemade”. However, the plate wasn't too full. A reservation is absolutely necessary.

Ambiance is ok, but the friendliness of the service is not appropriate for the high prices. Unfortunately, the food wasn't quite to our taste either. My wife was happy, but my daughter and I were disappointed. Six years later, the service is still not particularly friendly. We liked the food better.

One of my favorite restaurants when I'm in Norderney...very good food and very friendly staff

Great restaurant. The food is super tasty and the service is super nice and very attentive despite the restaurant being more than full. We had a great evening.

Awesome pizzeria! Great food, great service

Gigi is a remarkably competent service person. Ivo supports her well. Overall we received a good quality meal. Meat, fish, pasta... everything was very tasty, fried to perfection, delicious jus. Drinks good selection, white wine cold. Price level appropriate but not overpriced. Happy to recommend.

Everything was very good - it was the first time there 👍👍👍

Bad service, unfriendly staff I've never experienced anything like that, there were three of us but it wasn't possible for us to get our food together. We had to ask several times for the third dish and there are better pizzerias in terms of taste. We definitely won't be coming back then we'd rather have a fish sandwich the hand

Als Einstieg in den Inselurlaub o.k. Wir hatten Pasta mit Gambas für meine Tochter, die sehr zufriedne war, der Grillteller war o.k, aber die Pommes als Beilage total versalzen. Als ich dies dem Service gegenüber monierte, wurde einfach darüber hinweg gegangen. Nach der Bestellung der Getränke dauerte es 15 min für eine Flasche Wasser und eine Fanta, um an den Tisch zu gelangen.

Eating outside in the rain. The food was loveless and the pork fillet was probably no longer completely fresh. Service, if at all, very arrogant.

Wir sind 'Foodies', also kochen und essen gern, und wollten bei einem Italiener zu Abend essen. In das Lokal kamen wir überhaupt nicht, da keine Reservierung. Wir wurden sehr arrogant auf die Tische draußen verwiesen, 'falls wir etwas fänden'. Nun ja. Die Karte las sich vielversprechend. Die Bedienung ließ ewig auf sich warten. Wir bestellten Schweinefilets in Gorgonzola Sauce und die mediterranen Ravioli, Vorspeise Salat. Der Salat war gut, doch so, wie auch in anderen Restaurants erhältlich. Die Filets hatten einen leichten Gout, somit tauschten wir die Gerichte. Meinem Mann machte das nichts aus. Das Essen kam lieblos auf den Teller 'geklatscht' an, keine Dekoration, nichts. Die Ravioli waren nicht ausreichend und keine Gaumenfreude, man konnte den Inhalt nicht identifizieren. Wir bestellten noch Bruschetta anschließend zum Sattwerden. Nachdem wir darauf mehr als eine halbe Stunde warteten, sagten wir, wir würden sie einfach mitnehmen. Daraufhin kamen sie sofort mit der Rechnung. Beim Auspacken später: Matschig, das Brot war nicht geröstet. Viele Tomatenstückchen, kein Pesto. Eine Riesenenttäuschung, und die Preise der Gerichte waren in keiner Weise gerechtfertigt. Da dürfen sich gern andere an ihrem Essen erfreuen. Wir nicht.

Wir waren heute Abend zu dritt in dem Restaurant. Wir wurden an der Tür abgeholt und uns wurde ein Tisch zugewiesen mit der klaren Aufforderung: Den Tisch brauchen wir aber um 20.15 Uhr wieder! War schon mal ein guter Beginn. Zu Essen gab es für uns drei verschiedene Gerichte: Lasagne - Portion eher zu klein, aber sonst lecker Dorade Royal gegrillt - Mit Spaghetti; sehr gut, große Portion und wirklich sehr lecker. Preis war ortsüblich angemessen. Pizza Annina - eine Pizza, die eigentlich Hähnchenstücke, getrocknete Tomaten und Avocado als Belag haben sollte. Die Pizza, die kommentarlos auf den Tisch gestellt wurde, hatte nicht ein einziges Stück Avocado. Nachdem wir danach gefragt haben, wurde uns gesagt, dass leider keine Avocado mehr da wäre. Man hatte es aber nicht für nötig gehalten, uns vorher darüber zu informieren… Es wurde auch keine Preisreduzierung oder ein anderer Ausgleich angeboten. Kein guter Service. Bedient wurden wir überhaupt nur, wenn wir sehr proaktiv eine Bedienung angesprochen haben. Von alleine ging da leider nichts. Als wir gegangen sind und uns von der Bedienung verabschiedet haben, gab es keine Reaktion. wir wurden da eher ignoriert. Wir hatten die ganze Zeit den Eindruck, dass in dem Lokal nur gehobenes Klientel verkehrt und wir als „einfache Gäste“ dort nicht willkommen waren. Von daher gibt es leider nur 2 Punkte…

The food is very good. The service, especially at the reservation stage, seems unfriendly and annoyed and treats the guest as a supplicant. You can tell it's coming to the end of the season.

Table wobbles, waitress can't say hello. The last person's food comes when the first one is finished.

The food is very good and tasty (you should be very hungry for the pizza) and the service is very nice and accommodating. The food came very close. Price-performance ratio is okay, but you should definitely reserve a table in advance

Delicious food at a good price.

Very busy restaurant with solid Italian cuisine and fairly attentive service. Gladly again

We ordered antipasti and pizzas. The starter came relatively quickly... But then nothing else happened for a long time. A colleague then asked, puzzled, what was still missing, but again nothing happened for a long time. They had simply forgotten it and pointed out that we had to wait longer because of groups. But everyone else who came after us had already had their main course... It would have been enough to simply admit that they had forgotten their order. The pizzas finally arrived, but the quality was only average. Pizza didn't have artichoke hearts but also the entire inedible outer skin. When we wanted to pay, another waiter with glasses came and noticed that the amount was too high. As he walked away, he called out the correct amount in an incomprehensible and arrogant manner. Unbelievable, when he came back and we asked for the amount, he rudely said that he had already said that. Not recommended, arrogance and decadence at the same time. There are much better Italian places with reasonable service and no arrogance, where you are also treated correctly, sorry.

Sher tasty and high quality, but correspondingly expensive.

The food was tasty but unfortunately the portions were far too small. And unfortunately everything is pretty expensive!

I was at "Da Sergio" for the first (and probably last) time. My wife has been to Norderney several times and said in advance that we absolutely had to go there because it was the "in-Italian". We had reserved beforehand, but realized that we wouldn't make it on time and apologized over the phone that we would be a little late. When we arrived at the restaurant, we were greeted rather reproachfully and escorted to our place by the manager. Since we were sitting a little offside, my wife asked an employee if she could change seats. Of course, this had to be clarified with the boss and in a very patronizing manner she said “okaaaaay”. So the “romantic and relaxed dinner” suffered from negative impressions and a strange atmosphere right from the start. You didn't really feel welcome but rather tolerated... The gentleman who served us was very friendly and the food was nicely prepared and tasty. The grated Parmesan cheese my wife requested for the pasta dish was later added to the bill as €2.50. After paying the bill, we stood up while the “boss” was one table away. In my opinion, attentive people, who care about the guests and whose visit you should normally be happy about, notice when people leave the restaurant and you say goodbye and thank them for the visit, but that didn't happen either. Not a reaction to a "goodbye" - but perhaps you already knew that this certainly wouldn't happen. The gentleman at the checkout just before the exit door also reacted the same way as the boss: without words. Maybe the same applies here: "As is the Lord, so is the G'scherr"... hopefully the nice waiter who served us won't be the only exception. I would wish this to the mostly enthusiastic guests who may have been treated differently or who didn't notice it that much. Conclusion: great food and a great reputation based on the service...

Das essen soll scheinbar sehr gut sein dort, aber nachdem wir dreimal da waren und eine Stunde auf nur ein Glas Prosecco gewartet haben. Da es unser letzter Abend war, wollten wir eine schöne Flasche Wein von Grünhaus bestellen und Vorspeisen und Hauptgänge essen was die Karte geboten hat, aber niemand kam um unsere Bestellung auf zunehmen, vielleicht irgendwann, aber die Frage war dann eben wann. Also haben wir 8€ auf dem Tisch geschmissen und sind gegangen. Wir kennen uns in der Welt cuisine aus , aber wenn der Service nicht dazu passt verstehen wir die Welt nicht mehr. Service eine absolute Katastrophe und eine Unfreundlichkeit , unglaublich. Frage warum eine Restaurant betreiben. Ich glaube der / die Chef:in hat den falschen Beruf gewählt. Zwei Geschwister aus Schweden.

The service and the food are simply great.

It could have been 5 points because the food was great and because we were served well by the waiter. What just didn't fit was what is actually a must and doesn't cost any money at all: Friendliness at reception. Unfortunately, the allocation of the reserved seats only seems to be reserved for a single lady (by her habitus, the boss). She busied herself with other things within sight, let us wait on the stairs like supplicants for a few minutes and gave us the feeling that we were allowed to eat in this shop. With this kind of welcoming culture, our anticipation quickly disappeared. Because we weren't in the mood, we skipped the appetizer and the bottle of wine. It's actually a shame, because the main course was really great (like on our previous visits).

Waiter a bit too arrogant. Staff was totally overwhelmed

5 Punkte hätten es sein können, weil das Essen mega war und weil wir auch vom Kellner gut bedient wurden. Was einfach nicht gepasst hat, war das, was eigentlich ein Muss ist und überhaupt kein Geld kostet: Die Freundlichkeit beim Empfang. Die Platzzuweisung scheint leider nur einer einzelnen Dame vorbehalten zu sein (von ihrem Habitus, die Chefin). Die ließ uns auf der Treppe ein paar Minuten wie Bittsteller warten und vermittelte uns das Gefühl, in diesem Laden essen zu DÜRFEN. Bei dieser Art von Willkommenskultur war unsere Vorfreude schnell dahin. Mangels Stimmung haben wir dann auf die Vorspeise und die Flasche Wein verzichtet. Eigentlich schade, denn die Hauptspeise war wirklich (wie schon bei unseren Besuchen zuvor) mega.

We spontaneously decided to visit the Restaurant da Sergio on Norderney. We were positioned at an exciting “regulars’ table” and were able to enjoy the evening with like-minded people. The staff is very motivated and has solid knowledge of and around Italian cuisine. Daily recommendations were presented and ordered directly. Quality and cuisine ensure a very good experience of food and drinks. Price/performance is excellent and tempts you to come back. Thanks

Very good food and very nice staff

No. 1 Italian on Norderney, TOP fish, pasta, and much more. Absolutely fantastic wine list. Highly Recommended

Norderney is already very upscale. Pizza was actually one of the best I've ever eaten and the service was very friendly and accommodating

Nie wieder! Waren gestern im Da Sergio Essen. Die Speisen waren vollkommen in Ordnung. Das Negative jedoch ist, dass man sich als Gast nicht gut aufgehoben fühlt. Die Freundlichkeit der Angestellten lässt stark zu wünschen übrig. Wir waren mit Tochter und Enkelin im Da Sergio. Nach freundlicher Frage unserer Tochter wo sie den Buggy abstellen kann wurde sie von der Geschäftsführerin regelrecht unfreundlich behandelt. Sogar ein Mitarbeiter hat leise gesagt, daß man so nicht mit Gästen umgehen kann. Beim Bezahlen haben wir dennoch ein Trinkgeld gegen..man hat sich nicht einmal bedankt. Wirklich schade...nie wieder da Sergio Norderney

Good Italian in the upper class. The service was unobtrusive but appropriate. The portions were balanced, not too much but not too little either. The food is lovingly arranged and tasty. My recommendation to end the meal with a well-kept grappa. I'll definitely come back.

Wir haben eine Vorspeise und Pasta gegessen. Alles sehr lecker. Die Bedienung war aufmerksam und freundlich. Da das Lokal stark frequentiert ist, lohnt sich für Stoßzeiten eine Reservierung. Vor einem Jahr waren wir auch mit einer größeren Gruppe dort- u. a. mit einem dementen älteren Herrn. Trotz seiner Probleme wurde er zuvorkommend und verständnisvoll behandelt. Hatten Fisch, Pasta und Fleischgerichte- alle waren zufrieden. Die Preise liegen, wie fast überall auf Norderney, im höheren Preissegment, aber immer noch angemessen, wenn man die Transportketten für die Insellage berücksichtigt.

Very good food 👍 have been there twice. Great grill and steak and very good pizzas also gluten-free.

The tuna trio was great and was “addictive” for us (fresh, not “fishy”). Fillet of veal and fine fish fillet were also very tasty and fried to perfection, as were the side dishes, nothing to complain about. Only the rib fries that were served in a small bowl with the veal, apparently familiar frozen goods, were unnecessary, didn't really go with it and I didn't eat them. We also enjoyed our wine selection.

Best Italian 🇮🇹north of the Alps 🍕

As has often been said, the best Italian in the entire North Sea. Sylt is out anyway 😂