Borgo Antico Italiano Restaurant in Fehmarn

Very friendly, unobtrusive and competent staff!

We started the evening with a Prosecco. Unfortunately it was ice cold and without any carbonation. Probably not sold often! My glass of red wine was also far too cold. Starter "Bruschetta on toasted bread" - although the bread was barely toasted. When I ordered my "Rumpsteak Al Pepe Nero" I was asked how I would like it grilled. I chose "medium/well - no longer bloody". I was served a steak that was fried to medium rare and was still very rare. It had to go on the grill again and then it was okay. The extra vegetable side dish left many wishes unfulfilled. The "Salmone in Costa" that my wife ordered was very tasty. Unfortunately, the advertising slogan “We are the elite” is a long way away. The restaurant was comfortably furnished and the tables were not too close together. Given the price level, we would have expected better quality.

We had different meals and all of the meals were top notch, from pasta to overpackaged pasta to pizzas. Ordering a pizza half and half wasn't a problem either. The prices are absolutely fair for the quality offered. Update, we went out to eat again yesterday. Everything tasted fine. I ordered a russ. Wheat with Sprite. I also got a 0.5 soot. But a Sprite and a Wheat were charged for over €9, which really annoyed me... not like that.

The pizza was fantastic. Quickly at the table and tastes excellent. Top! Service very attentive and friendly. A visit is worth it.

Excellent food, super friendly staff and incredibly child-friendly!!! Rarely experienced something like this, THANK YOU!!

The staff was nice nonetheless. ..... Unfortunately we weren't satisfied at all. First we got an Aperol with about 80 percent ice cubes. After complaining, we were given a smaller glass with only 60-70% ice left.🙈 At the same time, our ASP justified himself by saying that he had completed special training in connection with cocktails and knew exactly what our order should look like. The pizza was soggy and therefore not exactly a highlight. I have a hard time with negative reviews, but it wasn't a nice visit to the restaurant... it's a shame!! The reaction in response to my objective report of my experience combined with the desperate attempt to insult speak for itself. Kind regards!

We've been there 4 times and will be back

Super delicious food, lunch menu recommended! Very nice employees.

No holiday on Fehmarn without going to Borgo Antico at least once 🍷🥰 We have been enthusiastic about the quality of the food and the ambience since it opened in 2015. The only problem… you don't know what to use because everything is so delicious. The team is great and very warm. Big compliment and best wishes to everyone 🥂

Were just there with the family. Food and service is absolutely top. A clear recommendation

Everything was perfect all around, the food was delicious, the service was attentive and friendly, and there were plenty of vegetarian dishes on the menu.

Excellent food and almost perfect service. By far the best restaurant on the island. An absolute recommendation.

Have ordered twice for collection. Very friendly staff, very quick preparation and very tasty. I can only recommend it. 🙏

Pizza Vegetariana very disappointing. Contrary to the description on the menu, the vegetables were not fresh. At least the peppers, which there was most of on the pizza, were canned. We couldn't detect any garlic either. The side salad was absolutely tasteless. Mainly iceberg lettuce, a cocktail tomato, a slice of cucumber, a long thin slice of carrot.

This year we “only” picked up food. It was ready on time and still hot. Just as delicious as if we had eaten there. In my opinion the prices are justified as the quality (at least of our food) was really good! Pizza was a bit thin for us, but still tasted TOP! Recommended on every level! 👌

Very friendly service and really super fast service ❗Keep it up❗

Delicious and delicate pizza dough, well-chosen toppings we are satisfied. ☺️😁Service great and pleasant 🥰

A super cozy place, sweet and polite staff and super delicious food.

The restaurant is very tastefully decorated. You immediately felt comfortable. The service was friendly and attentive. We were welcome with our dog. Our Pizza Tonno had a fluffy dough and was well topped. When I asked, I was given homemade hot sauce. It was finally an extremely good and wholesome pizza again. At the end there was a grappa on the house. We would love to come back.

We ordered two pizzas to take away. Including the antipasti pizza. The only point of criticism: for a pizza for 17 euros I expect a little more than 2 slices of eggplant, 2 small round, unfortunately also very hard slices of ham and a small corner of parika. Otherwise very tasty

Excellent! The problem, however, is that no comparable restaurant has been found so far. So only the long way to Fehmarn remains.

Food very tasty. Service very attentive and nice. The best restaurant so far for us on the island of Fehmarn.

Contrary to the bad reviews, I can say that the food was very tasty and the service was in no way unfriendly. Gladly again.

Nice Italian restaurant, friendly staff 😎👍

If you're on holiday on Fehmarn and are looking for a really good pizzeria, you can't miss Borgo Antico. A large selection of pizzas but also fans of stakes or pasta dishes will experience enjoyable food here. I had the Pizza Inferno. If you like it spicy, i.e. really hot, you should dare to order it. Despite the spiciness, the balance to the taste is maintained. Let yourself be pampered with culinary delights, we have already had the pleasure. It wasn't the first time there and it wasn't the last time either.

Nice atmosphere, very nice service, food very good

Delicious food (highlight the Bolognese, which I received upon request) and very attentive service. Highly recommended! 👌🏼☺️

Super fine food and - unlike most restaurants on Fehmarn - quite elegant. So it's a little pricey, but it's worth it! Even have some vegan options that sounded great. Personal recommendation: fresh pasta.

Very good food, with a pleasant atmosphere on the outside terrace. Food was also prepared very quickly. Highly recommended.

Very nice, upscale restaurant with delicious dishes.

Really outstanding authentic Italian restaurant with excellent service. The pizzas were fantastic, the service impeccable. It was particularly nice that (as is common everywhere in Italy) there was also espresso without caffeine. Absolute recommendation.

Beautiful Italian restaurant. The service is outstanding. The food without fault. The calzone was very tasty and well filled. Now arrived at the apartment and enjoyed the beautiful evening with the feeling of digesting an excellent meal. Greetings from the Wolfenbüttel district...

Expectations were quite high given the good reviews. However, the visit was very disappointing. Service was of the mass dispatch type, not a second too long was spent at the table. Drinks, Aperol, were completely different, sometimes watered down, sometimes strong. Vegan dishes are extremely bland and far too expensive. The rest of the food was okay, but tasted rather bland. Pasta is probably the better choice here. But the price is far above the quality offered.

Do you want to enjoy wonderful Italian food in the rustic ambience of a Roma Casa? Then you definitely have to come here. Prices moderate, the service friendly, the food unconditionally recommended.

Super delicious, we went there twice on vacation! It's better to reserve a day in advance. Very child friendly!

We have been reading in the restaurant while on holiday on Fehmarn for several years. The food is still excellent. But what was particularly positive this year was the friendliness of the staff. The food at the next table was simply served incorrectly - it can happen, with so many people it's not out of the question. The wrong dish was of course taken back, and a small dessert was offered at the house's expense without being asked - a small thing that costs the restaurant almost nothing, but does wonders for relationships with the guests. I would fully recommend the restaurant, good food, fast, courteous service, good selection of wines, despite not having a table reservation, never turned away - congratulations!! You understand how it works! Thanks for the great dishes!

Great pizza. Food comes quickly and the service is very nice. Gladly again on the next vacation.

Simply great pizza! We had Pizza Perfette and Pizza Picante and Tiramisu for dessert for lunch. The food was simply great, nothing more needs to be said. The service was very attentive and friendly. The waiters were fun with our two babies. A great restaurant visit!

A straight A in all areas, you can't say more!!!

Dogs are welcome, both indoors and outdoors. The waitresses and waiters are very attentive, friendly and accommodating. The food was very tasty, we had the vegan dishes, which were very unusual, but in Italian cuisine you don't have to miss out on anything. We sat outside and found it very comfortable, especially since the restaurant was on a side street, it was much quieter than most other restaurants nearby. Inside it looked very stylish.

A great Italian restaurant that invites you to linger at first glance with its stylish and cozy ambience. The natural and almost "caring" friendliness of the entire staff is impressive and made us feel very comfortable. Thanks for that! Finally, something to eat: starters, pizza, vegetarian pizza and, to top it all off, the Nutella pizza for the children - MEGA!!!

Ambience awesome. Gluten-free pasta and pizza were offered. Gluten-free pizza dough is prepared on Schär ready-made base and is therefore smaller than the others, but still delicious. Pizzas go into shared ovens with separate pizza trays.

You will NOT miss your favorite Italian restaurant. Excellent food (the homemade pasta!), from warm hosts, in a rustic atmosphere. The whole thing is child-friendly and at fair prices. My downer: I had to drive and couldn't try the great selection of wines. On your next visit :-)

On a recommendation we went to Fehmarn and came across this really beautiful restaurant. The food deserves more than 5 stars, we haven't had such good Italian food in a long time. It was a real culinary delight ♥️ the staff were all very accommodating and polite. Really a very nice restaurant.

Very friendly attentive staff, good food

Great Italian, fantastic food, extremely friendly and helpful staff. We are already looking forward to the next time.

Very nice Italian restaurant. Authentic. Super delicious pizza and pasta. Rose really great. Very nice and courteous service. Reservations recommended.

So far one of the best Italian restaurants I have visited in my life. Exceptional cuisine, top pizzas, delicious homemade pasta with great sauces and fresh ingredients. Top quality both in terms of craftsmanship and taste. Very elegant atmosphere, especially indoors, with a large selection of wines. Young, committed, very friendly and attentive team. A culinary pearl on Fehmarn. I think I have to go back to Fehmarn just to eat there. 🤪

We've been coming here for years, one of the best Italians we know in Northern Germany (as of 2023). 2024 This week was probably our 6th or 7th time here. We wanted to have a good meal with our two adult sons at the end of our vacation. Accordingly, I reserved a table that was as quiet as possible so that we could have a good chat. When we arrived on time we were kindly directed to the loudest table in the restaurant, right at the entrance to the kitchen. As soon as we sat down we were asked twice within 3 minutes if we would like to order drinks, which was annoying. The food was always very good, but unfortunately the drink prices, a 0.5 liter Kellerbier for €6.50, are now at the same level as Sylt. Overall, Fehmarn is very expensive - it has become too expensive.

Italian cuisine with several vegan options.

Ate here again today 8/3/24. Still a top address, highly recommended. Mega tasty, fresh, not a long wait. Always my pleasure!!! Keep it up!! Have just eaten here. Had reserved in advance. Very attentive, friendly staff. Really great ambience, great selection of food, very, very tasty, fresh food. Highly recommended. Have vacationed here and would eat here again on our next vacation. Excellent! Thumbs up!

Nice service, good food. To recommend.

Went there spontaneously at lunchtime with 4 people. Friendly welcome, even though it was just before lunch break. Food excellent, service very nice and accommodating. If we are on Fehmarn again, we would like to come back.

We were lucky that we reserved a table because the shop is very busy. It's very cozy and the ambience is great. The service is top. My steak was perfect and the salad was very good. However, the turkey was simply grilled for too long, partially burnt and of poor quality. The pizzas for the children were also perfect.

We just ate in the restaurant for the first time but certainly not the last. Service and food perfect. Best regards, Burkhard

We had bruschetta as a starter and then 3 different pizzas, which were also changed upon request, everything was delicious and the leftovers were packed up for us. We recommend.

We had reserved twice. Very tasty dishes. Even if you are very hungry, the portions are more than enough. Very child-friendly, upon request a small pizza was served in advance for our grandson. Clear recommendation.

As always, delicious and great condition

Really tasty and super nice staff...👍

Very tasty food, very friendly staff and a nice atmosphere. We will definitely come back here next time on Fehmarn.

Ambience, food, staff and prices are simply great. I have rarely eaten in such a good Italian restaurant. Molto bene.👌

Super tasty, great service. Gladly again. Also gluten-free dishes 👍😃

Best Italian!!!!! Really great cuisine!!!!! Thanks

We were there today and we really enjoyed it. Would love to come back.

From the reception to the starter, to the service to the main course, to the dessert and the wine, you can't eat and drink better. Best Italian far and wide. And we're really cute. Thank you.

A very excellent and chic restaurant. Pizza, pasta and some of the fish dishes are really outstanding, not just in Fehmarn but throughout Germany. I definitely recommend everyone to try this out! You can hardly eat better.

Since card payment is possible according to the answer, I would like to restore my original rating. Unfortunately I have to take back my 4 star rating because card payments are no longer possible. The reasoning is so absurd that it makes your hair stand on end.

We went to this restaurant twice during our vacation. Both times were a real pleasure. The ambience is very stylish, the service is very pleasant and the food was very good for all of us. I would say it was the best Italian restaurant I've ever been to. If we come to Fehmarn again we will definitely go there again!!!

Delicious, exceptional homemade pasta 😋 with prawns, salmon and fresh vegetables. Price performance great. Nice staff - Italian flair 👍🤗

I had a spontaneous meal with my family (5 people). Everyone ordered something different. Very polite staff, every meal was excellent... absolutely great evening. I can only recommend this Italian restaurant to everyone! Just great!!

We love coming back to Borgo Antico on Fehmarn every time! Very good food, very good service and cozy atmosphere!

Simply MEGA Great pizza, nice service Definitely going again next vacation 🤩 In summary: I Love it ❤

The completely different Italian - incredibly delicious food, very tasty - not a pizzeria! Very friendly, courteous service, everything is right here! grace

We had dinner there last month. Unfortunately we didn't make a reservation because it was very spontaneous. That's why we unfortunately sat in a tight spot. But it wasn't bad at all as the food was great. We had homemade pasta with mushrooms and a pizza that was incredibly tasty. The service was also really great and attentive. Gladly again.

Always worth a visit. We've been coming here to eat for years - whether it's pasta or pizzas - requests are catered for and everything is made possible. Service is always top! Even if you make a reservation with a stroller, you will receive courteous help - thank you very much for that! Changing options are available in the women's toilet.

Very nice atmosphere. Always very friendly and professional service. Food is always extremely good. We really enjoy being here and will continue to do so in the future.

We came across Borgo Antico by chance. The good reviews didn't lie. The ambience is really pleasant and the waiters are very polite and accommodating. We had very, very tasty bruschetta as you can see in the picture. We continued with two pizzas that really deserved to be called Italian pizza. A wonderful base with a very tasty edge. It was made with love and tasted damn good too. All in all, this was by far my best experience at an Italian restaurant ever. We will definitely come back and can only recommend that anyone who likes Italian eats here.

Everything ok, but not outstanding.

super nice & fast service and an extremely tasty pizza! (something different without classic pizza sauce) - again immediately!

Today we had pasta dishes to take away, which was very, very tasty. Once with fish, once with pork and mushrooms. Very friendly staff. Food packaged very well. Portion: plenty.👍 Gladly again.

Very nice, professional staff. The food was great. All in all, always happy.

Very tasty food and the service is always excellent. Also quick and easy if you order something to take away. Warm and delicious...we'll come back👍😊

As always, a great visit with first-class service and a great ambience. And my criticism is also at a high level: This time we're having the vegan pizza. It was also really tasty, but it reminded us a lot of the vegan bruschetta served before (and at least as delicious) with almost identical toppings. I understand that an authentic Italian restaurant has a hard time embracing cheese alternatives, but a little "cheesy" on this pizza probably really would have made all the difference for us. (Vegans don't find the cheese itself disgusting, just that cows and calves are included in it ;) )

The food was super tasty and the service was really exceptionally good. We felt very comfortable and would love to come back.

Delicious food Attentive and friendly service Price performance is right

The three of us just had dinner, I haven't eaten something so tasty in a long time! The service was courteous and extremely friendly. Absolute recommendation if you want original Italian food. Thanks

Very good service, the calzone was really very tasty, cross on the outside and nice and fruity on the inside and well topped. The ambience and service were really very good. I can only recommend it. 🎉👍👍👍👍

The three of us spent a very nice evening here today. The food was excellent, the atmosphere was really nice and the service was very courteous and extremely personable. Absolute recommendation.

We were there twice. The first time they were so accommodating. Because we shared a dish and it was served directly on two plates. Very polite service. So we went there a second time and were again served our shared meal on two plates. Gladly again. 😀

This is a very beautiful and very tasty Italian. The ambience of the restaurant is extremely beautiful. Both the area where you eat and the toilets. Everything furnished to a very high standard. The service staff is extremely friendly and accommodating and the food was outstanding. It's been a long time since I've eaten in such a nice restaurant where everything is perfect. Thank you for this lovely evening. I will definitely come again.

Highly recommended restaurant. We visited it 2 times in one week. Extremely nice atmosphere, great furnishings. The food was excellent across the board, whether it was pasta or pizza. The service was very polite, attentive. Good quality drinks, good wine list. Only the selection of open red wines could be a little larger. All in all, a thoroughly recommended restaurant with a good price-performance ratio. If we come to Fehmarn again, a repeat visit is guaranteed. Thanks to the team.

Best pizza, service is just great, very nice atmosphere

It hasn't been an insider tip for a long time - not just authentic, but really Italian, ideally located, great atmosphere, absolutely one of the best restaurants on the island!

Service and ambience are typically Italian, so great. We had pre-ordered vegan burgers (condition) for our repeated visit (previously vegan pizza and vegan pasta dish = perfect) and were shocked after the first bite because the 250 g hamburger was like falafel. I was quite disappointed for the price of €24 because I was expecting something Italian, at least not falafel dough, for this "upscale Italian" that is always full. So that was nothing.

Once again everything was great, very nice staff and always open to requests.

Very child-friendly service. The food came to the table quickly, freshly prepared and in sufficient portions. At the end, the portafilter machine delivers a perfect espresso in a hot cup, thanks to good employees! All in all, more than worth the price. Vegan dishes are very tasty!

Excellent dishes, very tasty and the ambience too

It was super tasty, some vegan dishes (yay!) and the staff was also very warm and friendly :) would be happy to come back

If you stop by, you probably won't get a table - but they'll mark you down - and it's worth coming back - guaranteed - five stars - gladly again 😎

The atmosphere is very nice and you immediately feel at home. Super friendly team.