Alte Mühle Bergstedt in Hamburg

The service urgently needs training. They are friendly but uncoordinated, I expect more given the prices. And TAP WATER for almost €8.00 is really OUTRAGEOUS. So far I've only had to pay extra for mayo and ketchup at the snack bar. Here I pay an additional €1 each!!!!! Is a no go. The food this time was rather mediocre

Just under 8 euros for a watery hot chocolate without cream with a splash (amaretto).. plus an unpleasant coolness in handling. no thanks, not again.

Good food, attentive service, ambience matches the character of the house.

I came across here while hiking...it's beautifully situated in the forest and by a lake. I will definitely come here. Unfortunately it was closed today.

Everything great. The food was extremely good. The portions were finally big enough so that you could eat well. The service was very friendly. The food came super quickly and was beautifully prepared. The atmosphere was also very pleasant. We'll be back!

I was really looking forward to the visit. Except for the arrogant waiter, everything was really nice. The prices are ok, the quality of the dishes is average and the ambience is great. But it is an absolute no-go that if you change an insert you have to pay the full price for the changed insert. A note on the menu or a note from the waiter would be correct. Or you would have had to serve both side dishes if both were charged anyway. We also found the portions to be a bit too small. It's a real shame because we think the restaurant is very nice.

Impossible waiter. Unfriendly to rude. After seeing me in the entrance! left the restaurant almost empty with the comment that he still had to look for a table. Leave me standing didn't come back. (Other spontaneous customers also simply went to a table). Then he argued with my husband...instead of being friendly. If the owner reads this, he should treat his colleague to training. After all, we are in Bergstedt and not on the Reeperbahn

The food was very tasty even if the steak was a bit small and came without a side dish.

We sat in a separate room with 16 people. alone

Very positively surprised by the cheerful and motivated service staff. I can only recommend it.

We went to the Haus am See for the New Year's Eve party and were very satisfied. The food was all very good, the service was attentive and friendly. We'll be coming to the restaurant soon.

Ate Kaiserschmarrn and apple strudel there. Apple strudel was tiny and lukewarm at best for €7.90. The Kaiserschmarrn portion was also small, even though it was stated for 2 people and at €17.90 it really wasn't a bargain. The cappuccino was not tasty. Service and atmosphere very nice!

New brooms sweep well and the saying is true here. Carefully modernized, very attentive service and good food.

Excellent and very nice service, excellent food and cozy atmosphere. It's a dream to sit by the lake in summer and cozy in the old mill in autumn/winter.

Unfortunately, I have to agree with the previous poster: We also had reservations for Boxing Day - and asked in advance whether normal à la carte service was possible; which was confirmed over the phone. Our guests who specifically wanted a restaurant with no Christmas menu; looked at us very sparingly and disappointed. After consulting with the waiter, the first question he received was an unempathetic "that's à la carte" and the second specific question about whether schnitzel was possible was a short "no" + "that can't be" in response to the telephone inquiry. The Alte Mühle couldn't turn the rest of the evening into a positive: the goulash soup tasted extremely good; unfortunately only lukewarm. Tables were pushed back and forth; Station atmosphere. Plates were only half cleared and there was no ice cream for dessert for the children. The main courses were fine; Value for money too. I give the 2 stars because I'm actually very happy that the mill is open again and there is a beer garden in this beautiful place in Bergstedt; However, something like that shouldn't happen - we could have thought of several things on the spot to save the situation; if you wanted to and saw the disappointment on the faces of a larger group.

We had made a reservation for a larger group on Christmas Day. Unfortunately there was only a special Christmas menu with typical Christmas dishes. It was not possible to order food from the “normal” menu. We thought that was a shame because we would have liked to have eaten something other than the typical duck breast, goose leg, etc. Since this wasn't mentioned when making the reservation or on the website, we left quite disappointed. The selection of dishes on offer wasn't very diverse and the prices were rather in the upper range. We've never experienced anything like this before...

You can finally eat here again after it's been re-taken over! Very friendly service, food good value for money, atmosphere was very nice! What more could you want!? In summer, take a break on the terrace by the lake or have a celebration in one of the cozy houses, life has returned here!

I went to another restaurant last night and I'm still loving it! I ordered the beef steak with herb butter and potato gratin, and it was just perfect. The meat was wonderfully tender, grilled to perfection, and the gratin was creamy and aromatic - a real taste explosion.

A delicious and very warming mulled wine, with a good portion of subsidy👌

If you're looking for an Oktoberfest atmosphere at Christmas with beer mugs and heather, this is the right place for you. We were thrilled in the summer, now disappointed. Tomato soup with mozzarella was served without mozzarella because it was out, we found out when we asked.

We were here with a large group and loved it! The food came to everyone at the same time, which is anything but normal with a large group. The service was extremely friendly and always tried to fulfill our every wish. We felt completely comfortable. Particularly noteworthy is the breathtaking ambience and delicious food! We'll definitely be back.

Wow found it via Google and was more than thrilled! Top service, very good food and the ambience is convincing. 3 courses because it feels too good to stop

Well….the food was below average. After ordering, the food came after 15 minutes. Kale ok, cold cooked sausage, canned sweet potatoes. Simply cheap and bad! Warmed up goose leg. Red cabbage miserable. No, the kitchen is not recommended. The service was super friendly, but neither refills nor asked questions. It's a shame, because the “hardware” of the restaurant was extensively renovated. Conclusion - you tried hard...that alone is not enough! The kitchen needs to be better.

Ready meals are served and as mentioned in previous reviews, glutamate is used. The decoration was done on a small budget. There is no criticism in this, but it is clear where investments were not made. I won't come back.

Plenty of good food, friendly service.

Very cozy rural restaurant. Nice ambience. Food very tasty and friendly service

I rarely have that! The Alte Mühle in Bergstedt scores in all categories. I had a Mühlen-Special burger with extra cheese (yes, there are no hyphens on the menu, but I'll forgive that), my wife simply ordered a burger without gluten and lactose. This obviously wasn't a challenge for the kitchen and was solved excellently. The components of the burger were individually prepared without a bun in a very appetizing manner and delivered as ordered. The mill special burger was outstanding (homemade and fluffy bun, excellent composition and ingredients, generous portion). The dishes from the other tables also looked excellent and this was confirmed by the feedback from the guests. The service was friendly and had an absolutely appropriate level of humor and conversation. The ambience is wonderful and a perfect mix of cozy, inviting and elegant, not at all outlandish but not shabby in any way. The prices may not be low (Mühlen special burger without extra cheese for 17.90 euros), but they are clearly worth every cent and therefore undoubtedly reasonable. Without question, my new favorite restaurant, easily giving hip burger shops a run for their money.

After the renovation, the change of ownership became really great. Food was very good and attentive service It's definitely worth coming here. It must be fantastic in the summer. We'll be back

Had a very good meal at the Alte Mühle last night. Super friendly and fast service, after the renovation the interior is finally so inviting without trying to be overly stylish. Simply the right location in a beautiful location where you'll enjoy stopping by! 😄

Very nice service and nicely decorated location. The roast beef was very tasty, it could have been just a bit more fried potatoes for our taste

Enttäuschung total. Waren hier mit 6 Personen, Männliche Bedienungen sehr forsch, fast unhöflich. Pannfisch trocken, bestimmt aufgewärmt. Surf&Turf trocken, bestimmt aufgewärmt, die anderen Gerichte so lala. Aber vielleicht war der Koch gerade in Urlaub

Great ambience...great food at affordable prices. Nice service👍 Very good...I'll be back

We ended up here by chance because we were in the area and were in the mood for fried potatoes. The Wiener Schnitzel was excellent, pretty much the best we ate in Hamburg and the surrounding area.

Great location and very attentive, friendly staff. Always my pleasure.

Going to this restaurant was a great experience with very kind employees. The food tasted great and they had much to choose from! Overall a great restaurant!

Very cozy, delicious food and friendly service. What more could you want?

We got married in the old mill last week and can recommend it 100%. The Haus am See is a wonderful wedding location! The food, the drinks, the service, the flexibility… we were very happy with everything! A big thank you again to the entire team - we'll be back for our silver wedding anniversary at the latest :-)

The ambience by the water and near the forest is great. The menu offers a lot of choice and the prices are very fair compared to restaurants in a similar location. The service is of a very special kind! The senior was very loud and cheeky towards an older guest. Almost didactic and know-it-all. The two conversations were so loud that unfortunately you couldn't hear them. The young female waitress behind us did the same as her colleague and addressed the guests behind us with the words “What’s your problem?” as one of them replaced the broken chair. The offer “How can I help you?” would be nicer. My salmon had herb butter and my husband had lemon with his beef - it can happen, but it's still not pleasant if foods are mixed up.

After a bike tour, we had a delicious coffee with milk with a view of the lake.

I think it's good that they're open seven days. I think it used to only be 3 days, so I asked myself what they deserve that they only have to open for 3 days.

Quaint, cozy location. Super friendly service, large menu, good food.

Burgers are pretty average, surprising for the relatively high price. I only know that the ketchup costs extra according to the menu from a snack bar and not a restaurant

Sat outside in the beer garden, everything was very good!

We had lunch with friends at the Alte Mühle today and were really thrilled. The selection of dishes was wonderful, the prices were reasonable and OK. The food was very, very tasty and nicely presented on beautiful dishes. We were served by a young, very friendly and approachable team. We felt very comfortable there and can fully recommend the location.

Food ok and quick Service was sometimes not friendly and slow View from the terrace 120 out of 100

Went indoors for dinner. Average in all respects. No ambience. It might be okay outside for a coffee/cake.

Great destination! Enjoy your meal. Nice service.

Especially when the weather allows you to stay in the garden by the lake, an extremely beautiful place. The kitchen is still good, but has unfortunately deteriorated somewhat with the change of ownership in winter 2023/24. The previously professional staff was replaced by numerous temporary workers, which unfortunately meant that the service suffered enormously.

Price performance really super good. Great spot in the forest by the lake, but also beautiful outside. Thank you very much

Very cozy and rustic, you can sit outside by the pond, the food is delicious and the service is great👍...Spade beer from the bike, delicious😋 Price performance is good🙃

Unfortunately, there is no longer the home-style cuisine as in the past. The new card seems a bit arbitrary and interchangeable, which is a real shame. The location is really great, something like this is rare in Hamburg. The service can and will continue to learn, unfortunately it is really difficult today, as in many other industries.

The restaurant is located in the middle of beautiful nature. We met friends here. The restaurant is also certainly suitable for family celebrations. The service and the food are consistent and very good. However, it was very loud in the large room on Saturday evening. A reservation is definitely recommended on the weekend.

A fantastic place to sit comfortably outside by the mill pond in summer. In the middle of nature. Super. We just drank coffee. The waiter was great and quick, even though the terrace was full.

Nice to sit in the beer garden by the small lake. Nice staff. Enjoy your meal A beautiful place in the middle of the big city

Great historic restaurant. The food tasted great. Price/performance is right. The staff were very attentive. Keep it up

Next to a small lake. Nice views in Summer. Outside seating. Food was good. Staff was also very nice.

Were in transit and went there on a recommendation. Great service, location right on the lake/pond, food excellent (we had veal schnitzel and surf and turf). Everything and also the beer/white wine spritzer there are of very good quality. The building and beer garden are very quaint, we are happy to recommend them.

Medium price range for such a good restaurant, great service... extremely friendly staff.

One of our favorite restaurants in Poppenbüttel. The food is always good and plentiful, the prices are not as crazy as in many other restaurants and the service has also noticeably improved. And it's wonderful to sit by the mill pond. The only thing I think is a shame is that you can't make a reservation outside.

New hospitality and new menu with a few old acquaintances. The food was delicious and the service was friendly despite the full garden by the lake

Great restaurant, nice atmosphere, delicious food but carbonated mineral water from the tap served in a milk bottle. It's a shame, one would have expected better water here.

Idyllic location with outdoor dining by the lake. Friendly and courteous staff. Varied menu with good quality food. But: Unfortunately, bottled mineral water (sparkling water) cannot be ordered; it is expressly only served at events. Very irritating. There is only tap water with added carbon dioxide. It's a real shame, you lose customers very quickly after a promising start.

All employees are very friendly and respectful. The food is delicious, nothing special but the cuisine is really good. It's nice outside in summer but you can't reserve a table outside. Inside is also very pleasant and relaxed.

Very nice, courteous service, drinks, food, everything worked out very quickly... very tasty...

Went there for a meal with 20 people, the food was very good, it was a shame that the side dishes usually cost extra and were poorly portioned. Price-performance ratio was appropriate.

Yesterday we spontaneously stopped for a beer, as always, very nice service and a wonderful atmosphere outside on the terrace.

Tasty and very, very friendly service, the time between starter and main course was a bit long

Very nice restaurant with a large outdoor area, ideal for small celebrations or simply for a leisurely meal. Extensive menu with many choices. The food is very tasty and beautifully prepared to the eye. The staff is very friendly, courteous and helpful. The visit is really worth it.

Perfect for a summer evening! Sitting outside by the not-so-small mill pond, surrounded by nature and trees and enjoying the food in peace - it wasn't the first time I was there (and not the last time either) 🌞

Food was tasty, sat outside, nice young staff 👍

Cozy guesthouse in beautiful surroundings.

It's a shame that this time the reserved table wasn't available and then, after waiting for over 40 minutes, no one had time to take care of us. After asking three times we left. Too bad. At least an apology for overload would have been appropriate.

I've walked past it many times. Never returned. Made better this time. Location is wonderful. Service very good. Ambience: better to sit outside! Can't be better. Try the extra card with chanterelles!

Great restaurant with very tasty food. (Hamburger Pannfisch) Nice and friendly staff. I would love to come back again.

Very attentive staff - had an apple crumble and a cappuccino - top

Nice place for a relaxing evening. Service was very friendly and tried hard, but since there was a larger event taking place at the same time that evening, it was a bit stressed and too sparsely staffed. Food very good, great and wide selection, prices are ok. You could also offer house wine at a more moderate price. Gladly again!

Best sweet potato fries ever! Service a bit inexperienced, but very committed and the ambience outside is rustic with a view of the lake, inside it has been newly renovated with a lot of taste.

I was here at lunchtime with my sister, it wasn't very crowded but it was very cozy outside, the waiter was nice, friendly and quick and the food was really good, I had a farmer's omelet (I thought it was very large) and my sister had a baked potato with turkey, both very good good

I was invited to a birthday party there in a nice little house by the lake. Everything was great for a cozy, relaxed family celebration with friends. Our selection menu with vegetarian, meat and fish dishes met the tastes of all guests. The service staff was very nice and helpful. I was allowed to operate the stereo system myself and put on the birthday child's desired CDs/tracks. The celebration house with direct exit to some outdoor areas with a view of the lake: absolutely wonderful!

We liked it very much. Food, prices, ambience, everything was great 😃

If the fried herring hadn't been "tranig" it would have been 5 points. The place is definitely recommended!

We really liked it. A diverse menu, fair prices, decent sanitary facilities and a beautiful location by the pond! But the best thing: good food and great staff, who were courteous and well organized. We will be back

Delicious food and attentive, friendly staff

Es war Mega schön hier!! Für unseren Hund gab es einen extra Napf🐶. Echt zu empfehlen ist dieses Restaurant hier. Natürlich auch bei diesem Mega Ausblick😍

Bei einem Spaziergang haben wir bei der Alten Mühle eine Pause gemacht und auf der Terrasse am Teich etwas getrunken. Der Service war freundlich und nett und die Bezahlung mit der Kreditkarte war auch bei einem kleinen Betrag möglich.

During a walk we took a break at the Old Mill and had something to drink on the terrace by the pond. The service was friendly and nice and payment by credit card was possible even for a small amount.

I still know the old mill from before. Now it has a new owner, but things aren't really going well yet. You definitely have to have a little patience. In any case, my son and grandson were very satisfied with the burgers. The staff is very friendly, but unfortunately the lack of staff is also noticeable here. If you want, you can sit outside very nicely. It's best to test it yourself.

Nice atmosphere inside and outside!!!Everything we have eaten so far has been very tasty and plentiful. Large selection of dishes and something for everyone. Prices are moderate for today's times. The restaurant manager is extremely friendly!!!It's especially nice to sit on the outside terrace by the lake when the weather is good!

...the food actually tasted very good, but as it turned out afterwards, it was seasoned with glutamate. Since I have glutamate intolerance, I noticed this pretty quickly. Since we only know this from Asian cuisine, I didn't ask beforehand. The use of glutamate is unusual in German cuisine. This has never happened to me in a German restaurant. Too bad………….

Very nice atmosphere inside and out.

Unfortunately, with the change of operator, the quality of the food has slipped massively. Inedible burger for expensive money. The interior design used to be much more stylish - now it's just uniform. Even a new operator can't ruin this beautiful place. The staff from before also remained, which is again a clear plus point.

Thank you very much, dear colleagues in the Bergstedter Mühle restaurant team, for your commitment and for the great European Football Championship evening with you!

Very nice restaurant in a great location, unfortunately we couldn't sit outside due to the weather. The change in operator definitely has a positive effect. We will be there more often.

Very comfortable! Super friendly staff! The food was also perfect! We'd love to come back :-)

We've been here several times. After the change in management and the renovation of the restaurant, we wanted to take a look at everything and see if the quality had changed. That is not the case. Although the menu has changed, the quality of the food is still excellent and the staff is friendly. Even though we are very satisfied, we miss the beautiful chocolates that were previously sold here.

Very nice atmosphere inside and outside. Went there spontaneously on Sunday afternoon and got a table without a reservation. Waiting time for ordering was about 15 minutes and 30 minutes for the food to arrive. The order came at the same time and the dishes tasted very good! Approximately 80-100€ for two adults and two teenagers.

Very idyllic place in the middle of nature - beautiful even when it rains

A very beautifully idyllic little restaurant. The restaurant is rustically furnished and has a nice atmosphere. In summer, even when the weather is nice, you can sit outside and comfortably look at the water. The price/performance ratio is completely fine. The food tastes good and is presented very clearly. There are few parking spaces available, which can quickly make parking difficult.

The "Alte Mühle Bergstedt" is a very nice restaurant with very tasty food and nice staff. Highly recommended.

We celebrated our wedding in the Haus am See in May of this year. In addition to the great location, we were very impressed by the delicious food and the friendliness of the operator. We had reserved the location with the previous owner, who left without a word about a change of operator. The celebration was then held by the new operators - it couldn't have been better for us. We always received quick answers to our questions, were able to look at the location several times, on the big day the staff were very attentive and friendly and everything was to our complete satisfaction. Our wishes, for example regarding the menu, were fully met. We would definitely book here again for the next big celebration.