Trattoria i Siciliani in Frankfurt am Main

Vorab: Der Betreiber lässt negative Rezensionen auf Google entfernen. Das Ranking ist also mit Vorsicht zu genießen. Wir hatten am 9.11.2024 eine Tischreservierung auf 20:30 Uhr, weil wir den Geburtstag meines Vaters feiern wollten. Dafür waren wir extra 45 Minuten aus dem Umland angereist. Am Restaurant angekommen stießen wir auf eine Schlange von etwa 15 Personen am Eingang, die aus unterschiedlichen Grüppchen bestand. All diese Menschen hatten ebenfalls eine Tischreservierung und manche warteten schon seit über einer Stunde. Nach und nach gaben einige der Wartenden frustriert auf, wodurch die Schlange kürzer wurde und wir einen Blick in den Wintergarten erhielten. Im inneren waren die Tische und Gäste sehr eng zusammen gestellt. Auf uns machte das einen ungemütlichen Eindruck. Unsere Hoffnung lag auf dem Gastraum, den wir von außen nicht einsehen konnten. Insgesamt warteten wir 40 Minuten im Eingangsbereich, der mit gasbetriebenen Heizstrahlern geheizt wurde, gemeinsam mit anderen, ohne auch nur einmal vom Personal angesprochen zu werden. Anschließend sind wir unverrichteter Dinge wieder gegangen. Wir kennen einige gehobene Restaurants im Umkreis und so etwas ist uns noch nicht untergekommen. Wenn man im Vorfeld einen Tisch reserviert, erwartet man, dass dieser bei Ankunft bereit ist. Wir sind maßlos enttäuscht von dieser Art mit Gästen umzugehen. Falls es dem Betreiber darum geht, den Umsatz zu maximieren, indem er alle Tische durchgehend belegt hat, dann soll er doch bitte keine Tischreservierungen annehmen, die er nicht beabsichtigt zu erfüllen. Was wir hier erlebt haben, lässt sich nur als unseriös beschreiben. Der Laden und vor allem der Betreiber hat sich die schlechte Bewertung redlich verdient. Eine absolute Unverschämtheit!

Cibo ottimo. Preparazioni accurate. Cucina siciliana tipica e rivisitata. piatti di pesce e carne spaziali! Caponata bomba e molto altro. Consigliatissimo!!!

Wow! Very inconspicuous, but wow!

Completely overbooked when we arrived. We had a reservation, and there was a big crowd outside also with reservations. The staff gave no updates what so ever, and when we finally managed to get in contact with one, she couldn't say how long it would take. It seems extremely chaotic, and the indoor setting seems very outdated. Its very 🤨 suspecious with all the good reviews. Stay away. 🚫

Nice ambience, but that was it.

The dishes are carefully prepared and visually neatly presented. In the beautiful atmosphere, the service appears friendly and competent.

Excellent! Always happy again!!!

Very good food. Dumplings with truffles, homemade bread with olive oil. Pride.

Beautiful experience, friendly and very helpful staff The taste of fantastic food that could not be removed from the palate We found the environment serene and very relaxing I recommend it to everyone We will be back we had a great time

Ich bin zum erste Mal hier gewesen.Das Essen war lecker, alles aus gute Qualität und sehr gut vorbereitet, die Bedienung sehr aufmerksam, die Atmosphäre angenehm. Sehr zu empfehlen, ich werde wieder kommen

Great, delicious food. We ate the 4-course gourmet menu. The staff wasn't particularly friendly, but we still felt comfortable :)

Very friendly service. Pasta with squid and shrimp was really good.

Very tasty food, fish with capers. Not far from city Old Town. Good wines too. Thanks, your cook is a master!

Italians with a focus on Sicily. Carpaccio with truffles and rocket was very tasty. Also fish with cucunci. Thanks

An average store in all areas. You can do it again but it's nothing special

The pasta was delicious, the starters could be better... but the tiramisu took it out again 😋 Service and ambience is great!

We had a table reservation for 8:30 p.m. because we wanted to celebrate my father's birthday. When we arrived at the restaurant we encountered a queue at the entrance. All of these people had reservations and some had been waiting for over an hour. Inside, the tables and guests were crammed together like they were on an economy flight to Bangkok. The operator's calculations can be quickly deduced here. Everything here is designed to maximize profits. We can only speculate as to where savings will be made in the kitchen, despite the high prices, because after 40 minutes of waiting we left without having accomplished anything and without the staff having spoken to us. The store and especially the operator really deserve the bad rating. An absolute disgrace!

Excellent food and friendly staff 👌

After our visit to the restaurant, the extremely high rating of 4.8 stars is incomprehensible to me. The service was handled quickly. The food was very below average for a normal Italian restaurant. If you then have to pay €33 for a main course and the restaurant is described as a “gourmet restaurant”, then that borders on being cheeky.

A restaurant with an Italian touch, I am not used to eating "non-traditional" dishes, however this place was a pleasant surprise.

GREAT KITCHEN!! Highly recommended!!

Der typische Italiener für um die Ecke!!! Einfach Klasse. Atmosphäre, Ambiente und Service passen einfach. Man könnte meinen man wäre auf Sizilien. Ein gemütliches Ecklokal mit einer tollen Küche. Wir sind öfters hier, und es ist immer wieder sehr angenehm hierher zu kommen. Alles wird schön präsentiert, ist frisch und hat einen kräftigen sizilianischen Touch. Selbst Wünsche wegen gesundheitlicher Besonderheiten setzt die Küchencrew perfekt um. Und wenn mal nicht, ein kurzer Hinweis und schon passt es wieder, ohne das ein Kellner am murren wäre. Überhaupt das Personal, ist sehr freundlich und aufmerksam. Alles in Allem fühlt man sich hier gut aufgehoben.

The atmosphere of the trattoria and the Sicilian cuisine make you feel at home. Professional and welcoming staff towards customers. Amazing food. I recommend it 👍🏻

Welcoming environment, qualified and friendly staff 😁 not to mention the high quality food and drinks!

Because of the great reviews, we were looking forward to a nice and culinary Italian evening yesterday. The disappointment was great. This had very little to do with Italian cuisine as I know it. I ordered the herb-crusted sea bass with ratatouille (caponata). There was no crust except for pieces of roasted potato floating in oil. Ratatouille was overcooked vegetables that had been ground into a paste in the blender and had the perch soaked in herbs... the taste was actually almost inedible. My wife had a pizza that stayed in the oven too long. But otherwise you could let it pass. The lamb fared like my sea bass and the pasta dish was stuffed pasta in creamy mush. Antipasti were 4 small bites of sea bass, cheese and eggplant, and small squid on ready-made pesto. The wine was fine... The price was massively overpriced. After our complaint, we were served an espresso corretto on the house, but that couldn't really compensate us... we'll definitely never see this restaurant again. One point for the service and the attempt to make amends…

The place is a little too small although very colorful and welcoming. Speedy service. Very normal pizza. Too expensive! Not good quality/price ratio!

The food is very good without any debate, but what is very shocking is the prices. It's way too expensive for what you get. You can't charge over €17 for 10 gnocchis, I assumed a good filled plate. When I go to another restaurant I get 16 gnocchis for just under 11 euros and they are miles better. When I had dessert I almost fell to the floor and thought that with the sorbet you could get something for over €9. None, a small pot with 2 balls. Rarely am I so shocked by a restaurant that is so expensive and gets so little for it. Therefore I will avoid this restaurant in the future.

Unfortunately very disappointed, it was really extremely expensive and my Tonno Pizza was missing half of the cheese. Unfortunately, taste is nothing either. Sorry.

Great Food, nice atmosphere, good food

Unique experience, wonderful place, excellent food, unique property, see you soon

Fabulous place you can breathe the air of Sicily. Excellent wine, qualified staff. We'll see you soon

I haven't eaten something so delicious in a long time!

Stunning place, really excellent food, high class wine.. recommended. I will come back for sure

Wir haben für 17 Uhr einen Tisch reserviert. Wäre nicht nötig gewesen, das Restaurant war leer. Wir konnten wählen geheizt draußen, EG oder 1. Sock oben. Oben war es sehr gemütlich, zwar alles sehr eng, aber typisch italienisch. Bei der Antipasti Sicilia haben wir uns beraten lassen. Teils warm, teils kalt. Sehr gut geschmeckt. Wir hatten spigula canazzu, burro e salvia, Gnuccuni a surrintana und paista nivura. Alles absolut geschmacklich einwandfrei. Die schwarzen Nudeln etwas zu al dente, der Seewolf hätte mehr Salz vertragen. Aber man konnte ja nachwürzen. Das Sufflet chocolato spitzenklasse. Ein schöner Spätnachmittag. Lediglich die Männerlastigkeit war etwas überraschend, im engen Ausgang standen 3 kräftige Männer Spalier. Unfreundlicher Abgang.

Wow rating One of the best Italian restaurants in Frankfurt. It is spread over two floors, the upper floor where there is a small room, the kitchen and bathroom are not accessible for wheelchairs. Munu available in paper form or via QR code. Good choice of wines. We had a mixed starter, really good, and some lamb. Friendly staff and very attentive to dining needs

Now where to start, I had great expectations because of the many good receptions but there were plastic parts in the food! Drinks way too cold! I chose the meat menu for 60 euros!! decided, the 4 courses were very small, sauce had no taste, meat was dry, potatoes were more than soft-boiled! Dessert, 2 tiny pieces of ice cream with chocolate syrup from the tube... Service (depending on the waiter) arrogant and unfriendly! Toilets...no no words!! People who say the food was good have never been to Italy!

Authentic Italian food. The drinks are good and the food is even better. Plenty of seating and kind staff.

The pizza was ok so far, but it was a bit tiring to order the pizza. 5 people and one card?! The online menu doesn't show all the dishes and is a bit tiring to read. A restaurant should have multiple maps and not refer to an online map.

Das Essen war sehr lecker. Die Tische stehen etwas eng zusammen.

The restaurant is so cozy, dishes were so delicious, service was also good 😊 unfortunately they don’t serve pizza every day

Delicious pastas and pizza. Service was wonderful. Would come again.

Great place with very good Sicilian food and wines.

For our birthday we ate here, the waiters were super kind and nice, they even played happy birthday music for the cake! They were really kind!!! We ate a really excellent Sicilian starter and as a first course linguine with seafood feutti and black ravioli filled with burrata and sea bream and as a second course an escalope with gorgonzola, asparagus and two potatoes. What can I say, nothing short of exquisite!!! Highly recommended!!!!!😚😊☺🤗

Very nice restaurant though the entrance seems a little hidden. We walked on by before we realised we had completely missed the restaurant. Glad we went back. We both ordered daily specials with truffles; gnocchi and ravioli respectively. Service was impeccable. Espresso perfect.

Very tasty food, a little more expensive but the price is worth it. Delicious carpaccio, with enough truffles. Excellent orecchiette with salsicia. The Truscie are also very good.

Francesco and Daniella were the best! I felt like I was home again in Philly! Incredible food, service, and atmosphere!

As a starter I had carpaccio with truffles. There was a lot of truffle on the carpaccio, which was too overpowering for me personally. So I didn't finish the appetizer. For the main course I had the black pasta pockets. They were very tasty, but very al dente for my taste. However, you can taste that the noodles are homemade. The service was ok. Quite impersonal and disorganized at times. It was quite cool in the winter garden because we were sitting right in the entrance area. All in all, this is a great restaurant for anyone who prefers more unusual Italian cuisine.

Francesco and Daniella were awesome! Food was Michelin Star worthy! Starter sampler was fantastic, and the veal medallions were outstanding! A hidden gem in Frankfurt! Would recommend to locals and visitors alike. Molto Bene!!

Service is very slow and inattentive. Food good and reasonably priced.

The atmosphere there was really very nice. Unfortunately, the waiter came to the table far too rarely, we had our plates in front of us for a long time after the starter until they were finally cleared away and the main course arrived. I had the mussel pasta with pesto, which unfortunately didn't taste like anything. The stuffed ravioli with truffles, however, were good. It was a nice evening, but we won't come again because the price-performance ratio didn't match for us

The Linguine Frutti di Mare was delicious. There was plenty of fresh seafood, and although it smelled a bit like flour, the raw pasta was well cooked. However, the rest of the food was a bit weak for my taste. I was wondering if I could season it with olive oil, pepper, and salt, but I was disappointed with the flavor that came from seasoning the ingredients together during the cooking process. Other than the menu, I don't know why they charge more than other restaurants. The house wine was very cost-effective and delicious.

Well-kept place, exceptional staff, super super good food!!! Top hospitality... we will return, but above all we recommend it ❤️

Congratulations for your seriousness and experience in the sector... very nice place

A nice place to relive a bit of Sicilian atmosphere even while travelling, we had lunch here and what can I say, excellent food accompanied by excellent service. I highly recommend it!!

Very nice restaurant with good food and very competitive prices. The service was very superficial and not customer-oriented. They probably didn't need it, there were enough people there. I would like to say that I expect more when I dig deeper into my pockets. It was a nice evening but we won't be coming back.

Les plats étaient très bons, méditerranéens à souhait, et très généreux. L’accueil y était très chaleureux, et le personnel bienveillant et attentif. L’endroit était agréable,

Very unfriendly service, they ignore the guests and make insulting comments.

The food very moderate for such high prices, unprofessional waiters trying to sell antipasti, we were 5 persons and orders two antipasti and a salad and main course each, but the waiter was insisting we should go for two more antipasti because food was not enough, we let him propose and he brought a plate costed 21€ that had small pieces of cheese, calamari, augbergine etc a portion for one or max 2 persons. We paid 300 euros including house wine for a moderate food. Not recommended.

Subversion of macaroni and béchamel sauce. Must try if you come.

The restaurant is very cozy and the staff is very friendly. The products are purely Sicilian and that is appreciated. I recommend trying the pasta since it is the new and special thing about the place. The fish I ordered did not surprise me. I highlight the kindness and smile of the waiters.

Very good food but very unfriendly staff, especially if you don't order a starter

Excellent food. Very nice atmosphere. Exceptional Care. Definitely Highly Recommended. And of course I will be back very soon..

Appetizer was fantastic, so was the warm bread that came along with it. Main entrees were okay. Veal was a bit gamey and pasta with shrimp was fine but a bit underwhelming

Great place to visit with a small group

Price performance ratio is not right

Spectacular place, excellent food, I will definitely return

If you want to get insult while paying, please come.

What a great evening. Sensational cuisine. The starter and main course were outstanding and the dishes left nothing to be desired. What wines. It was a celebration for us and we will definitely come back.

We made reservations 2 weeks ahead and showed up on time. The waiter was rushed and kept telling us that the kitchen was busy and there was no menu and when we requested pizza we were denied and basically rushed and ignored. The service was deplorable and honestly even if busy, that is no way to treat patrons. The food was mediocre at best. We both ordered black pasta with truffles, it came in a curdled-looking sauce and the raviolis were made with fresh but very thick pasta. It was a very disappointing experience and excuses like being busy do not fly!!!!

Amazing sicilian cusine in Frankfurt! Top restaurant! You will feel like in Sicily! Top service too!

Everything delicious, when I return I will repeat

Excellent quality of food, knowledgeable staff and above all a very welcoming place.

Excellent food, perfect service, very kind and professional, welcoming and peaceful environment

I can't quite understand the stars, but well, tastes are different. Pizza 2/5 Pasta 2/5 Lasagna 3/5 It's ok but not worth the effort to drive to Sachsenhausen.

Hervorragendes Essen, exzellenter Service und das alles in sizilianischer familiärer Atmosphäre mitten in Frankfurt…? Dafür gibt es einen Namen: Trattoria i Siciliani! Bis zum nächsten Mal! Valentina del Fiore

Cozy place with friendly staff. Excellent food with Sicilian products. I will definitely return.

What happened to this place??? It was a nice neighborhood restaurant before, and this time, they served us literally pizza swim in soup, it was sooo wet. And also serve the bottle of wine which totally not related to the one I ordered. I feel like be treated as a fool

Impeccable service, truly quality wine and dinner

Excellent value for money... Really good food

Highly recommended ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Top food ~ professionalism, quality and competence.

The reviews here convinced us to eat here. The food was good. However, the service left something to be desired. We didn't feel welcome, I imagine it would be different with an expensive meal. Maybe it was the children who weren't welcome, I don't know. In any case, it was a shame.

We waited an hour for the order to be taken. The staff constantly ignored us and were super unfriendly when talking to us. The food was average but totally overpriced.

Full marks from us. Already started with the online reservation. We changed the number of people twice and everything worked fine. Confirmation came within minutes. Food was perfect. My wife says it's the best Italian ever, and we've visited many Italian restaurants... Thank you for the very nice evening. Keep it up...

Rustic atmosphere, delicious food.

My husband and I loved this place. The food was so delicious and attended service is amazing. We recommend it and we would be back soon.

A very good time spent at the table, thank you.

The staff wasn't really friendly and seemed annoyed. The starter is not recommended because it was absolutely not worth 22.50 for four small parts. The pizza was okay but nothing exceptional.

The first thing you have to do is make a reservation, otherwise go upstairs and you will find a table and they will greet you The tiramisu is amazing and everything is amazing

I ate an excellent pistachio-crusted lamb with roast potatoes on the side. A restaurant that I highly recommend to anyone who wants to eat Sicilian in Frankfurt. The manager is very kind and you can see that he works with passion. The environment is comfortable and welcoming, very homely. I will definitely return as soon as I'm in Frankfurt again.

Ambiance was OK, but service was very inattentive, we were often ignored even though the plates and glasses were empty. The food was OK, but in my opinion the P/L ratio isn't right here.

I was in a trattoria last week, a very welcoming place with exceptional food... thanks for the welcome

Amazing restaurants! They understand my preference and making great service. Most importantly, they know about their food! The food is prefectly prepared and tasty! The ingredients are well matched and the cooking techniques are quite good. The lasagna and truffle dumplings are both perfect! The waiters are also very considerate!

Highly recommended!!! Very tasty food and extremely nice people! The service here was great. Pleasant atmosphere. Top!!

Best Italian starter ever. Main course also delicious. Very good, nice advice. Had a lovely lunch there.

A piece of Italy in the middle of Frankfurt. The food is bombastic. Fresh, authentic and above all super tasty. The ambience is just like a trattoria in Italy. One of my favorite restaurants in Frankfurt

Excellent place, delicious dishes, highly recommended

Great local in the heart of Sachsenhausen

A traditional, owner-managed restaurant with great attention to detail and a beautiful terrace. The food and wine list is very extensive, you will find something to suit every taste and budget. If you come by car, you can even park directly opposite in the parking garage 🙏👌👍

Cozy and clean quaint restaurant. Delicious dishes prepared with first choice foods. Clean. Polite and fast staff. I advise

A place that deserves so much... good extensive menu and high quality food