Trattoria i Siciliani in Frankfurt am Main

Spent 1 night in frankfurt & found this gem on google. Lives up to the 4.9+ star hype. Delicious food. Great atmosphere.

I'm thrilled, the food tastes excellent 😋, and the service is very friendly. I highly recommend it. Five stars ⭐️

Overrated place. Waiters are rude, they always speak Italian and we don't understand anything. Wines are overpriced. Meals are so-so, nothing extraordinary. We asked for the check several times but they were very slow. The place is also very small, it wasn't comfortable.

The truffle pasta is top notch!!

Our favorite Italian restaurant for years! Excellent Sicilian cuisine of the highest quality. The attentive service and excellent wine selection leave nothing to be desired. We always enjoy coming here; we definitely recommend it!

It was, quite simply, the best meal I've ever had, including in Italy.

I went because of the good reviews, but I have to say the atmosphere is nice, but I've definitely had better pasta at other restaurants than here. I find the prices extremely overpriced, and you don't get anything special for that. I wouldn't go again; I assume the reviews aren't as accurate as they should be. There was no pizza on the menu either, just to make it clear.

Despite high ambitions: Culinary and conceptually unbalanced The tables are far too small to adequately accommodate everything that was served and offered to us. Furthermore, the seating is so close that there is no privacy at all – conversations at the next table are inevitably overheard. We found it unreasonable to have to work our way through the dishes and wines on offer with the help of a cell phone, iPad, and blackboard – Corona is long over, and in our view, that is neither hospitable nor contemporary. The food was generally well-prepared, but the approach was inconsistent: When you're promising authentic Sicilian cuisine, fried potatoes in a porcelain chip bowl as a side dish to four lamb chops for €35.50 seems out of place. The sea bass with pistachios and paprika purée was a bit more creative, but was also served with the same unimaginative fried potatoes. The price and quality were out of balance for us. This impression continued with the wine: Bottle prices start at €39.00, which seems very ambitious given the usual purchase prices. Ultimately, we received a bottle worth €59 for €39, as two of our desired wines were unavailable—a fair move, but one that only marginally improved the overall impression. The service was attentive, but not consistently present or approachable. Conclusion: Overall, the concept seems unbalanced—both in terms of cuisine and price. Those seeking authentic Sicilian flair and cuisine will probably not get their money's worth here.

A bit cramped, Food not outstanding Staff friendly Can be done. :)

We had a reservation for four people and received a very friendly welcome. Despite the full house, the food arrived relatively quickly, which was a pleasant surprise. Everything tasted truly delicious – both the starters and main courses were impressive. Unfortunately, the portions were much too small for our taste, especially considering the rather high price. For the money, you simply expect a bit more – both in terms of quantity and the overall experience. It's a shame, because the ambiance and service were otherwise excellent.

Excellent Sicilian cuisine in Frankfurt, excellent service, and you can even bring your pet along for lunch.

The restaurant's interior is very cozy. It's not large, but it has a certain charm. The wine list is fantastic, and if you want it, the wait staff will guide you through the evening. Having been there several times, I can say that everything I've eaten so far has been delicious. I definitely recommend the restaurant, but also the lasagna and the gnocchi with ricotta and walnuts.

A very pleasant welcome, delicious cuisine, a truly good time that I recommend.

An Italian restaurant worth trying, reservations are required

A welcoming restaurant with attentive service. The dishes are well-made, but the prices are high for what remains of pasta cuisine. The Italian ambiance also comes at a high price for the side dishes: €17 for two bottles of Italian water (San Pellegrino is admittedly a bit far from Frankfurt, but still!). Fortunately, service is included.

No doubt why this is 4.9 stars. Great food. Never had eggplant with the available recipe and orange Tiramisu is must try!! Must ask for spicy oil!!

True italian food. We got fresh bread with olive oil on the house. Tried the truffle gnocchi and they had this cheesy filling inside, super flavorful and delicious, must try. Friendly staff and the atmosphere is cozy. Definitely recommend.

Lovely wine, homemade pasta with great quality ingredients! Simply delicious!!! We were there for my mother's birthday and had a wonderful time! The staff organised a great candle for her to sing happy birthday and had music and lights. Just great!!! Grazie molto!!!

We were looking forward to a top-notch Italian restaurant. We found a rather average restaurant; everything was good, but not a 4.9 rating. It was also rather expensive.

The starters were very good. At €22, one would have expected a bit more from the pasta dish.

I went for dinner with my wife, the atmosphere is very cozy, the food was delicious. The service was excellent, everything was perfect. When I'm in Frankfurt again, I'll definitely be back.

Trattoria i Siciliani Ristorante Italiano is a wonderful restaurant of Italian cuisine. Who loves Italy and its cuisine, I advise you to visit this establishment, which will please you with a huge selection of amazingly delicious dishes. The service is also worthy of praise

Today, on May 17, 2025, we ate at an Italian restaurant that's one of the top 10 in Germany. We sat on the first floor at a table for two. Unfortunately, the smell of the food got stuck in our clothes. The kitchen is very close, and the smell draws you in. My tip for you: Don't do what we did; choose the ground floor instead. Unfortunately, I forgot to take photos of the food. The taste was excellent! But the portions are quite small. Don't be surprised if you see the portion sizes on the plates. I can say that I left the table hungry. But I tasted some very delicious and unusual flavors. I highly recommend making a reservation before going—the restaurant is in high demand. We ordered the house wine (red wine)—it was quite strong. I drank it very carefully, as it could have made me drunk. But he was good.

The price/performance ratio isn't right here. For this price range, you have to point to a sticky sticker with a QR code that opens a simple PDF – after all, a menu is a restaurant's calling card. We sat inside, where it got incredibly stuffy. The waitress(es) were very arrogant towards us. We weren't quite sure whether she was showing us to our seats or just telling us to go past her; when we asked, she just rolled her eyes. No smile and very brusque, but she behaved completely differently towards our neighbors in suits and dresses. The food was good, but I won't be coming back.

The food was good, but the service was poor. You get the feeling that the tables are being taken up by the next guests as quickly as possible; it's a bit like a mass processing operation.

Unfortunately, we witnessed the manager's unfriendly attitude toward both customers and staff. Furthermore, despite reservations, all the tables were occupied.

It is perfect and it is high quality and cheap the staff and the owner take care of the customers very well and it is very good from the inside

Nach einem hektischen Marsch durch die Innenstadt fanden wir hier eine Oase der Gemütlichkeit! Sehr nett eingerichtet, netter Service und gutes Essen! Das war wirklich köstlich! Ich komme wieder dorthin! Grüße aus Köln!

I only ate a salad with shrimp. It consisted of iceberg lettuce with a bit of arugula, underripe tomatoes, and flavorless pomegranate seeds. For €21, it was a mediocre experience.

Authentic Italian Taste in Frankfurt!

Wir haben eine tolle Familienfeier und einen wunderschönen Abend in der Trattoria I Siciliani verbracht. Das Ambiente war außergewöhnlich gut, der Service hervorragend und das Menu ausgezeichnet.

Fue una de las peores experiencias de cocina italiana que he tenido en mi vida. Primero, no hay un menú adecuado. Es como un rompecabezas. En segundo lugar no hay pizza para una trattoria y la pasta con ragu fue una de las peores que he tenido en mi vida. No sé cómo este restaurante obtuvo esta calificación, pero no es totalmente recomendable.

Tolles Restaurant!!!! Am 10.05. haben wir unsere Konfirmation in diesem tollen Restaurant gefeiert. Die vorherige Kommunikation und Abstimmung war toll und reibungslos. Man ist auf alle unsere Wünsche eingegangen. Es würden verschiedene Menüvorschläge unterbreitet. Alles frisch zubereitet und zusammen serviert. Einfach wunderbar. 26 Personen haben gleichzeitig ihr Essen bekommen. Es wurde jeweils 3 Vorspeisen, Hauptgänge und Dessert zur Auswahl angeboten. Einfach TOP 👍🏻 Der Service war sehr aufmerksam und nicht aufdringlich. Gewünschte Getränke, oder Extras wurden schnell serviert. Es war ein tolles Fest mit sehr leckerem Essen und Wein. Alle Gäste waren total begeistert vom Essen und der Lokation. Wie kommen gerne wieder 😊 Vielen Dank für alles!

Simply amazing! I was there yesterday with a friend and there was absolutely nothing to complain about. I'd love to give it 6 stars.

It was one of the worst Italian cuisine experiences I have ever had in my life. First, there is no proper menu. It is like a puzzle. Second no pizza for a trattoria and the pasta with ragu was one of the worst o have ever had in my life. I do not know how this restaurant got this rating but totally not recommended.

Great food, atmosphere and super friendly staff. They also were dog-friendly

Unfortunately the price-performance ratio doesn't fit at all and the service was rather adequate, not attentive, annoyed and we had to wait too long for everything. Not worth it...

Rather average. Price-performance ratio doesn't fit.

Very tasty food at its best, but it also has its price, ambience very nice and cute, small and elegant, but a bit outdated, service not good enough for this price level, it took a long time until they came to check on us

A wonderful place with Italian style and passion for cooking. The service is at the highest level, especially Francesco 💪😁👍 I am delighted and devastated because I won't eat anything this good even in Italy and I'm too far away to visit you at least once a month 😁 Best regards, and I have to visit you next time I visit Frankfurt. For me, 3 Michelin stars 👍👍👍

Dieses Restaurant scheint nur Fans oder massive Gegner zu haben, beides wird ihm finde ich nicht gerecht. Das Restaurant ist dem Italiener um die Ecke weit enteilt und es gibt viele durchaus interessante Gerichte die weit weg sind vom Standard. Nur viele Gerichte sind so super dann auch wieder nicht und die Preise passen eher zum sehr edlen Italiener. Nein wir waren zwar schon öfter hier, aber das Restaurant wird in Zukunft nicht mehr mit vorgeschlagen. Versprechen und Wirklichkeit passen zu wenig.

Great atmosphere, fast service but very few halal options.

The food is delicious but the waiters are very rude. Even though the restaurant was empty, they took us to the farthest corner. We don't understand Italian, but the facial expressions say it all! We definitely understood that they were talking about us and joking with each other. It's annoying and ridiculous that they keep asking if it's over even though we're not done yet.

Quality Italian products. I usually avoid Italian restaurants abroad, but I recommend this one.

Great restaurant. Reservations are required during holidays, otherwise there may be no seats. Fortunately for me, we arrived at the restaurant very early that day and there was room. Half an hour later, the restaurant was fully booked. There seems to be no English menu, but the waiter will suggest meals.

A place that makes you feel at home. The bread and pasta are made on site, the coffee is excellent and the service is outstanding. We loved it!

Great pasta. Run by real Italians. Good service. Fantastic olive oil and good bread. Honoured our discount voucher without any issues. Close to Städel Museum. Nice patio, and offered to seat us there. Would gladly return again when I am in Frankfurt.

Excellent and welcoming environment Exceptional service, friendliness and excellent staff who welcome you with humor and professionalism Food cannot be removed from the palate What can I say? Seeing is believing, we've been there and I recommend it to everyone You won't regret it

This is the fifth time I've been there. First of all: the kitchen is outstanding. The food was a dream. But the last few times we've noticed that the service is a bit - let's call it irritated - when you don't order starters and the once friendly tone turns into a very quiet ignore. Well, maybe it was just a feeling. Went there today and ate with the 4th for €220 (plus €20 tip). And the feeling was not deceptive. On the way out we passed 3 waiters and said goodbye. Not a smile, not a Ciao Grazie or anything. NOTHING. None of the waiters noticed that all 4 of us noticed that this was very inappropriate. According to the motto: money has been paid, service has been done and now disappears. This was very unpleasant and should definitely be clarified by the owner. I'm sorry about the food, which I rate 5* in this review, but for the money it's a no-go that we haven't encountered in any restaurant before. Too bad

Everything tastes good, the wine is also super tasty The service is also top

As a first experience I can say that I enjoyed myself, exceptional service, peaceful and quiet environment, excellent and friendly staff Excellent food that you couldn't take out of your mouth I recommend it to everyone and will return

I had a truly extraordinary experience at Trattoria I Siciliani. Starting from the super kind and helpful welcome, up to the high quality food with a unique flavour! Congratulations 💯

I recently had the pleasure of visiting Trattoria I Siciliani and I must say that it was an extraordinary experience! The atmosphere is welcoming and the staff is incredibly friendly and helpful. The food was simply delicious, with dishes prepared with fresh, high-quality ingredients. Every bite was an explosion of flavors that left me speechless. Furthermore, the service was impeccable: waiting times were short and the staff was always ready to satisfy my every need. I highly recommend La Trattoria I Siciliani to anyone looking for a memorable experience. I can't wait to go back!

What a fantastic, authentic Sicilian restaurant. The team is great, really good. Fast service, food is delicious.

thank you for this experience, the stuffed black pasta is a spectacle

You really feel like you are in Sicily. Very refined place with a wide choice of Italian wines... I recommend it

Unfortunately, we had a very annoying experience (March 30, 2025) and we still think about it sometimes. First of all I would like to say that the food is absolutely outstanding. As a birthday present we bought a voucher for 4 people on Groupon for €150. This was treated like a "crime" and we were immediately second rate guests. After a huge drama in front of all the guests, it was initially questioned whether the voucher was even valid. We ordered €105 worth of drinks alone and gave a generous tip. We would have spent enough money on drinks in any case, but it wasn't until we ordered a bottle of wine that we noticed that the waitress became somewhat "friendly". To be honest, the evening was ruined for us. When you go out to eat for €250 you expect a good atmosphere - that was simply gone. Otherwise you can also order food home. It was the first time for us to use Groupon and that's how we first became aware of this restaurant (with really good food) and would definitely have come back again if the service was normal. I don't understand why a restaurant would offer something like this if it is such a problem. Please, in God's name, don't offer vouchers like this if you then treat your guests so incredibly unkindly. I would have preferred to eat a Margherita pizza for €30.

Delicious food and wine. Attentive team. Sadly as not from Frankfurt can not keep coming back

I highly recommend this restaurant. Great service delicious food.

The first impression from the outside is deceptive. Once you get through the plastic curtain and fan heater, you are pleasantly surprised by the ambience. Then came the mega delicious starter. Would love to come back for a main course.

Everything tastes excellent and authentic. Very Italian, you get advice and the service makes suggestions...

Very tasty noodles. Absolutely recommended

Great restaurant with good food and a nice atmosphere

Excellent quality. The true Sicilian translations

True class. Excellent service, very welcoming, and incredible food. My new favorite spot in Frankfurt!

It was an experience worth repeating. Hospitality, cleanliness and delicious food are the strong points of this place. Seven of us had a fantastic evening and we will be back very, very soon. Congratulations to all

A rude hour-long wait, despite a reservation, and rude service. The waiters don't want to work there.

An ideal place for a nice Italian meal. The service is excellent, so is the food, and the staff communicates wonderfully. It is best not to go without a reservation.

Top! The service is very professional and nice. The food is also amazing. I was there with my Husband and we would like to lunch there again. To repeat for sure! We recommend.

Food is delicious but courses come much too quickly

Ottimo posto accogliente cucina ottima consigliato personale molto professionale diverse varietà di piatti ottimi

Excellent cuisine, wide variety of dishes, top marks

We were there with friends and will never return to this restaurant. We ordered two glasses of red wine and a cup of tea. We were served the cheapest mint tea in an espresso cup - that's just ridiculous... And the wine tasted horrible. I don't understand how this restaurant can have such high ratings.

The food was extremely tasty, again at any time

Ein sizilianischer Weißwein der Spitzenklasse, frische Pasta, aufmerksamer Service, vorneweg hausgebackenes Brot mit Olivenöl. - Ein Abend ganz oben auf der kulinarischen Hitparade,

Super Service, Essen Weltklasse !! ❤️❤️ Come visit!! Alles Haus gemacht und frisch.. Werde ich bestimmt beim nächsten Mal nochmals kommen.

Amazing pasta. We took the truffle pasta and the veal ones. Very tasty!

This is my second visit. If you want Sicilian food in Frankfurt, this is it! It's a very delicious restaurant. We have gnocchi full of fresh seafood! Both the pizza and tiramisu were delicious! The olive oil and balsamic vinegar that come with the appetizer bread are made in-house and are a little different. The staff is also very happy! and will welcome you in a friendly manner with Italian enthusiasm. Many of the interiors are Italian, so you'll feel like you've really come to Italy. We went without a reservation around 5pm on a weekday and got in easily, but by the time we left, it was almost full, so we recommend making a reservation during busy times. I will use it again on special days!

I found myself in Frankfurt and came across this Italian restaurant Trattoria i Siciliani very welcoming place excellent service really good food

It was perfect for a Sunday lunch. We ordered 3 main courses, all pasta dishes. “Gnocci a Surrintina” consists of homemade gnocci stuffed with cheese. The gnocci were very soft, too soft for me personally, but that didn't affect the taste as they were very tasty, especially with the mozzarella. “Gnuccuni cu pestu siculu” were gnocchi stuffed with cheese and ricotta in a very creamy ricotta sauce. I didn’t try the “paccari cu I’ammaruni”, but it was very nice. The portions were not large, but more filling. The place also has a nice little terrace that gives off a real Italian atmosphere and the service is quick.

Great experience! The restaurant was small and cozy and there was also a heated terrace outside. The atmosphere was authentic Italian, down to the music, even though we visited at a quiet time in the afternoon. The service was friendly and the food was overall excellent. We ate crabs and burrata (Ammaruni burrata) for starters, pasta filled with lamb ragout and truffles (Truskie c' agnieddu e taitufu) and cheese-spinach-filled tortellini (Tortelli pestu Liparisi) for the main course. For dessert, chocolate fondant and ice cream (Souffle al Cioccolato). We will definitely come again!

Italians with a focus on Sicily. Carpaccio with truffles and rocket was very tasty. Also fish with cucunci. Thank you very much!!!

Very nice place, excellent quality food...everything went in the best possible way

Beautiful place, top experience!!

The food was very tasty and the atmosphere was very cozy. The 'nice' gentleman in cemetery blonde greeted us very rudely and unfriendly. According to other reviews, such a reception is apparently generally miserable. So we were asked to go out into the cold again.

Food was delicious. You can do it. A little salt was missing. The bread was fluffy and delicious. Prices and portion sizes were fair. All you can eat olive oil and balsamic vinegar

Exciting and cool decor, the food was ok. I ordered something different than what I received. Abiente was nice.

We reserved a table last week. There wasn't much going on that day at 5:30 p.m. and the service employee seemed very overworked. When ordering, she forgot a drink she had ordered - which, after further memory, only came with the main course. We were greeted with 'you have 90 minutes' - which spoiled the impression of the good atmosphere and the evening. The food was okay, a bit dry and tasteless, but for the price of 18 euros for the lasagne it was very high. Unfortunately, I wasn't impressed with the visit and unfortunately doesn't live up to its good reviews

The food was really tasty and at the end there was a limoncello on the house, even though the bill was also very high. Very authentic and also very comfortable.

Great food, poor atmosphere and slow service. Cheapest wine on menu was €50 per bottle, with most €100-200 per bottle so we had aperitivos which was an odd pairing with pasta. Front room had red lights that felt like you were in an indoor marajuana farm. Tables were too close together and felt very cramped. Not a relaxing customer experience.

Be sure to try it! Homemade red wine and carpaccio were excellent. I chose the fried seafood platter, it was amazing!!

Italian restaurant. 4 stars for the environment for the tables, small essentials. I ate excellent pasta and drank excellent Italian wine. Good, honest price, friendly and nice staff.

Beautiful place, excellent friendly and kind meals

After many visits over the last few years - now it's over. Food must be selected in the restaurant using a QR code; there are no longer menus. Wine advice: none Prices: Outrageously high for what you get. Friendliness: Typical arrogance and snootyness that is common in this type of restaurant. Toilet: Don't laugh / it's really like that... The urinal in the men's toilet is so low that in fact - which the traces also prove - most men "just urinate on the floor" :-) Just disgusting. There are clearly better restaurants in FFM, all of which are in the higher price range, but where you also have the feeling of being welcome as a guest. Here one had the impression: the operators don't want any more. Food details: - The goat cheese as a starter was a very small portion, lukewarm, the fig dressing was barely noticeable (costs €2.5 if you make it yourself) - The pasta from the main menu was quite hard, no not "al dente", but hard, sauce unseasoned. For the prices, "remarkably" little Italian cuisine. It's like an Italian Ferrari... Nice to look at - but not suitable for everyday use and simply pointless.

Way too expensive for what it was. The service wasn't that great, won't go again.

We just left the site and we were served by Francesco and Daniela. They were so good with us and very very helpful. All of the stuff basically Thank you!! Definitely coming back Greetings from Greece 🇬🇷 Angelos

Best pizza I've ever eaten (number 5). Any time! There are also QR codes for the card.

Fabulous place with really good food ☺️

It was wonderful, I highly recommend it and I will definitely be back! 10/10

Very little portion for a very high price. Gas heating on the outside is totally wrong as you breathe literally gas.