Ristorante La Commedia in Stuttgart

La Commedia hat bei uns einen extrem positiven Eindruck hinterlassen. Ein sehr gepflegtes Ambiente, die ausgewählten Speisen waren exzellent zubereitet. Der Service war hervorragend. Der Gastgeber Luigi Aracri und Piero Cuna und sein TEAM haben uns auf dem höchsten Niveau serviert und ist sehr zu empfehlen! Mit freundlichen Grüßen Alessio Verga

I always like going to la commedia because everything fits here. Not cheap. Who wants cheap?

Everything is just right here! The restaurant is located on the edge of the city center and can be easily reached on foot. It impresses with a great ambience, excellent Italian cuisine and a selection of top wines. The price-performance ratio is great. Open continuously.

I really enjoy being there. Professionally and privately.

Terrible! Waited an hour for food and then the waiter gets mushy when you point it out to him. That's not his fault, it's the boss's fault. Food was a disgrace for the price. Not good quality. Knife that was lying on the floor was passed to the next guest.

I will not have the opportunity to comment on the cuisine of this restaurant because we did not have the pleasure of being received - indeed tables were available but "not for us"

It's time for a review. I have been an enthusiastic visitor to the Renitenz Theater since it was founded. Since then the location on Büchsenstr. I am currently a member of the club. We are particularly excited about the integration of the La Commedia restaurant into the theater. This flowing transition from the restaurant to the foyer is brilliantly solved. You can relax and enjoy the meal before the performance and then go straight on to the performance. I like to reserve online via opentable.de and it works perfectly. However, a lead time of 1-2 weeks is often advisable if you prefer a specific area or area. Especially during patio season. The staff is excellently trained, friendly, quick, attentive... No matter whether they are regulars or new guests. Fresh, high-quality products - a visible kitchen where everything is relaxed and professional. Price performance fits - an experience. If there is anything to complain about, we will respond to it promptly and in a friendly, problem-free manner. There is a TV and smoking area, a lounge area with bar and the restaurant with a flowing transition, as already mentioned, into the theater foyer. Restaurant and foyer recently redecorated. Very appealing. To feel good.

Es ist ein großes Restaurant mit einer großen Glasfront. Das Licht ist abends angenehm, nicht zu grell, nicht zu dunkel. Die Auswahl an Speisen ist sehr breit gefächert, man findet sehr gute Vorspeisen, Primi Piatti, Hauptgerichte und Nachspeisen. Das Personal ist sehr freundlich. Die Lage neben dem Hospitalhof lädt richtig ein ins Restaurant zu gehen, wenn man von einer Veranstaltung dort kommt, dieses Mal nach einem Vortrag mit Diskussion mit dem Soziologen Steffen Mau. Das Restaurant ist sehr zu empfehlen.

Very nice atmosphere, fast service, very nice. The food is also delicious, the beef tartare wasn't as I know it but was okay. It was just raw meat without any side dishes. As I said, it's a matter of taste but I know it with a little bit of garnish inside. The main courses are delicious. I have to say, the price is very high, but I think in return you have an upscale audience and a nice ambience. For a good meal you have to charge at least €70/80 per person.

Food heartless and not of high quality. Service friendly but intrusive. Price-performance a disaster. Ps. Not recommended

Been there again after a few years - unfortunately no comparison to before. The quality of the food is top. In terms of price, however, there is also a limit to what I am willing to pay. The hard-working and competent staff are in constant use - and that's where it starts. 1-2 waiters too few for the many seats and it becomes hectic which the guest also feels. With 8 people at the table, keep clearing away the already empty glasses and plates... the plate is hardly empty. No sharp knives for the pizzas - with normal cutlery it becomes an annoying challenge to eat a pizza. Sure, if you ask in an exasperated way, the person asking the question gets better cutlery - but only that person. Something like that should be brought to the table for everyone who has ordered a pizza. It is these and similar little things or mistakes that unfortunately downgraded the visit to the level of an average Italian ristorante, a rather cheap pizzeria. That's why it's unfortunately only 3 stars. And even though the food was great, we're going somewhere else for our end-of-year dinner next year.

Zur Einstimmung für das Renitenz - Theater der optimale Auftakt. Sehr gute italienische Küche stilvoll präsentiert. Professioneller Service und gute Qualität haben Ihren Preis. Ein gelungener, Abend, zu empfehlen!

Good but “tourist trap” feeling. The pizza was however good and the pasta quite well made. A smoking area is available inside. Great restaurant, lots of space. I agree with the comment about the tip almost demanded at the end of the meal and the difference in treatment between regulars and new ones. Price a bit high, 8 euros per bottle of water. It is probably easy to find better Italian cuisine for less money. For tourists, I recommend looking for another restaurant!

Great fusion of Italian, Turkish, Greek food. Delicious. Great service - gladly again.

Wir waren, zum Glück für den Besitzer, geladene Gäste am Sonntagabend. Was uns als stilles Selterswasser serviert wurde, war eine Frechheit. Die Flasche war offen und ohne Verschluß. Es war ganz sicher Leitungswasser. So schmeckte es auch. Was sicher auch die Lebenmittelüberwachung interessieren würde. Die Spaghetti Carbonara haben auch nicht das Geringste etwas mit dem Orginal zu tun. Ich kann es ihren Köchen gerne einmal zeigen.

Much better than many Italian restaurants, warm and welcoming environment.

In the foyer of the Renitenztheater. In the lower area the ground was quite cool on Saturday. Food is delicious, the salmon was grilled to perfection. Cooked and juicy, the zucchini not too soft or too hard. The tiramisu was the best I've eaten in a long time.

Great service, friendly staff and delicious food. Thank you very much!

Great restaurant, food is always top quality, waiters are very attentive

Very friendly, warm welcome. Nice ambience. The starter, an eggplant casserole, was fantastically delicious. Afterwards there was pasta with fresh porcini mushrooms and a tartare with fresh white truffle, both fantastic. A wonderful Verdicchio was recommended to us, perfect! The seasonal products on the memory card are very pleasing. All in all, a wonderful evening of great enjoyment.

Beautiful, elegant restaurant with a quiet, cozy atmosphere. The waiters are very nice and attentive. The food is fantastic! Very tasteful and fresh. If you like good Italian food, you have to go there at least once!

Waren vor dem Theaterbesuch hier essen und es war einfach toll. Die Vorspeise, Oktupus , war lecker, die Pizzen superlecker. Der Kellner war sehr nett. Es war ein sehr schöner Abend. Sind halt Stuttgarter Preise …..

West eaten twice very nice and very tasty. Pizzas are very good and in the Italian way :)

Very friendly staff, great food and a smoking area. Inside. Mega.

Stumbled across this great italian restaurant, brilliant.

Great restaurant, great food, perfect wine, fast service

Chic restaurant. Very pleasant atmosphere.

Well, I wouldn't go here, if only because of the price-performance ratio, because in my opinion everything that isn't pizza is offered at too high a price. The actual chef was sick so should we choose a dish that has nothing to do with pizza??? Why we weren't offered one or two dishes at a correspondingly cheaper price is still a mystery to me! Suddenly a "substitute pizza maker" was there, which fortunately led to the amount of the bill being reduced significantly. I can describe the food, service and ambience as consistently good, but not the pricing.

Das schlechteste tiramisu seit langem und dann noch abstreiten dass Sahne verwendet wurde den Gast vom chefkellner auch beschimpfen zu lassen auf italienisch setzt dem ganzen noch die Krone auf

Very nice evening, with a great aperitif, food, wine 🍷 the service is super professional, and you sit nice and well, you actually don't want to leave. Thank you for the wonderful evening. 🫶⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Il ristorante è molto grande all' interno e ha diversi tavoli all' aperto. Il personale è gentile e il nostro cameriere parlava perfettamente italiano. Abbiamo preso 3 pizze : calabrese e due tonno e cipolla, poi bruschette al pomodoro. L' impasto della pizza non è male anche se è un po' alta quindi rimane un po' gommosa . I prezzi sono un po' alti

Seriously: a pizza with vegetables 18.50 euros??? And no, the "vegetables" are probably neither truffles nor porcini mushrooms... That was my last visit.

Requires a surcharge upon collection. I'll contact consumer protection tomorrow. It's nowhere apparent.

Unfortunately not recommended. The prices are simply excessive for what you get.

Upscale ambience with outdoor area. There is also a smoking area inside. Service was nice and attentive. The dishes are beautifully presented. We enjoyed it. The prices are more in the upper segment. If you have difficulty walking (walker, etc.), the toilet is actually not accessible.

Very expensive for the quality and quantity of dishes. I'm very sorry to have to say this, but the tagliatelle with bolognese was salty and didn't really taste any better than a ready meal from the supermarket. We also had to wait a long time for our dessert even though it wasn't busy.

On the occasion of my birthday, my friend surprised me by visiting La Commedia. Unfortunately, the request for a nice table and the reference to my birthday were completely ignored. Instead, we were directed to a table outside right next to the entrance without any sign of hospitality. After we were allowed to move at our own request, we ended up in the bar area. The service was anything but attentive, we had to take action ourselves with every order. The burrata for €16.50 was on par with the one from the supermarket. The sauce on my seafood pasta had a very questionable consistency and the shrimp in the pasta were overcooked. Given the hefty price of over €20, this shouldn't happen. Unfortunately, only the dessert and our drinks convinced us. To sum it all up: Unfortunately, there's nothing wrong with this restaurant, apart from the external impression and the much better treatment of regular guests than everyone else. We won't be coming back and unfortunately we can't recommend the restaurant.

Nice restaurant, nice environment, very kind staff and very nice owner.

Always very tasty food, my favorite, the seafood salad, beautifully presented with always friendly service. Because of the many beautiful tables outside and the beautiful ambience of the hospital courtyard, you almost feel a bit of Italian flair!

Once again a wonderful evening with delicious food, great aperitif first of all, great wine! Service very attentive!!! This makes dinner fun 🤩 We'll be back soon 🥂

Place recommended by an acquaintance as the best for pizza. Not quite so in my opinion. I had pizza salami.

My husband and I didn't like the table we were assigned. Since there were still several tables available, we asked if we could have another table. Answer: “Then go to another restaurant.” Shortly after us, two young ladies arrived and were allowed to choose their table. I will refrain from further comment.

The restaurant was overall disappointing. The service (would-be manager at the reception with faded "branded clothes") was miserable and unfriendly, which made the entire visit unpleasant. The food was merely mediocre - some dishes were unreasonably gross, while others had barely any flavor (pizza isn't hard to make!). Given the quality, the prices are completely excessive and unjustified. I will not recommend this restaurant.

Service is really bad. People should respond more to customer requests. Food is ok, but we haven't reinvented the wheel either. Have eaten here a few times now. Food always tastes different somehow. Probably whoever is cooking.

So if you can't refine a tuna salad or adapt it to the customer's wishes by adding cheese, ham and egg, I'll cook it at home next time. These ingredients are all there, I didn't ask for half a beef on my salad. In my opinion this is a snooty shop. PS I don't care about spelling mistakes. No time actually for the post and no time to correct everything I've made a mistake. The massage is clear Thanks for nothing people.

Delicious food (pasta vongole!), open wines are a bit overpriced

Very good Italian restaurant - great value for money. The menu card is diverse but selective.

We ate well (lunch), service and atmosphere a little cold.

1 point for service. Far from Italian food and not a single trace. Hard spaghetti and canned porcini mushrooms - impudence. We don't have any parmesan spaghetti. We don't have truffles. The kitchen is getting worse and worse. Were there for the last time yesterday!!!!

The food was very tasty. However, with a few small exceptions, the service was unfriendly and unprofessional. The early reservation several months in advance in the outdoor area was not taken into account because of the statement that everything outside was already full. And then the complaint was responded to rudely. Don't be their fault if the staff didn't note it. My mistake, but probably even less so. Outrageous. It's a shame because the food was very good. Still, never again.

Staff unfriendly, waited more than 50 minutes between starter and main course… Friendly recommendation Dear owners (more staff)…

As visitors to the Renitenztheater, we couldn't pay for two drinks in the Commedia because payment with a cell phone/card only starts at €15. Think about it. This is not customer-oriented and has nothing in common with the reality of 2024

My spaghetti from the cheese wheel was completely over salted. Dessert was delicious. Service was okay, I found the prices too high.

Great food, excellent wine selection, pleasant location - great for people watching!

Centrally located restaurant in Stuttgart Mitte. Italian cuisine that really has something to offer. The pizza was great, the price was absolutely reasonable, and the service was top-notch. I'd love to come back here.

As always, we were very satisfied and will be back

Very simple and welcoming place, very good food, nothing to criticize! I liked it a lot

Wanted to surprise my girlfriend with a special dinner at an Italian restaurant for her birthday. The boss succeeded completely with his menu suggestion. We had a wonderful evening. Compliments to the good cuisine and the competent staff.

Lage ist gut. Service freundlich. Die Karte ansprechend, Qualität scheint gut. Für wen 20€ für eine (kleine) Vorspeise normal ist, der hat sicher Freude.

Incredibly rude service, even by Italian standards ;-) The food was okay, upper middle class, but ultimately grossly overpriced. The reception was downright grumpy, there was probably some quarreling internally, which shouldn't have bothered us as guests with a reserved table. In the menagerie there were leftover vinegar in the olive oil and fruit flies in the balsamic vinegar. The waiter wasn't interested.

Had a delicious dinner alone the other night. Linguine alle vongole was very nice with the panna cotta. Service was good at first and died by the end of it.

The two of us in the restaurant 1x monkfish that was totally dry with a dollop of spinach for €39.50 1 x pizza, there are much better, cheaper ones in Stuttgart. Have 1/4 PIZZA wrapped.... folded in the aluminum foil..... Conclusion: poor quality at exorbitant prices, but pseudo-elitist behavior. Can you forget...

Simply a great restaurant with great food. Not super cheap, but top quality!

Very A1 Condition 1A I'd be happy to come again

Daleko najbolji talijanski restoran u Stuttgartu. Odlična hrana, pogotovo steak na koji se uvijek vraćam kada dođem u Stuttgart. Osoblje me svaki put iznova oduševilo, veseli i uvijek nasmijani. Obožavam ovo mjesto.

Perfect evening, perfect meal. Always my pleasure.

Unaufmerksames Personal. Die Speisekarte und das Essen wird arrogant und selbstgefällig auf den Tisch geknallt. Das Preisleistungsverhältnis ist total verfehlet. Die Messer sind stumpf. Das Personal verschlimmert das ganze noch durch das Auftreten. Bei jedem Dönerimbiss um die Ecke wird man freundlicher bedient. Der gute Ruf basiert hauptsächlich auf den lokalen Politikern, etc. die hier ein und aus spazieren. Das sollte aber kein Zeichen für gute gehobene Gastronomie sein.

Great Italian restaurant with plenty of options, both in terms of classics and specialities. The bruschetta tasted great and their sourdough bread was also very nice. The black truffle parmesan pasta was also extremely tasty, although it did get a little sickly after a while. The service was a bit slow given it was a fairly light night in terms of guests. I also found the price difference between main dishes with meat and pastas / pizzas had a large disconnect that is perhaps unreasonable. Overall a great location with authentic Italian food, so would recommend.

Very bad service. He brings the wrong drink, you complain, he says just drink it, then I bring the right one, but still puts the wrong drink on the bill and argues with the guest. The drinks are good, but that's not how it works. Antisocial behavior!

Very nice and attentive service. Super tasty and beautifully prepared food. I can only recommend it and I would love to come back.

what a beautiful and elegant restaurant, you feel like you are in Italy. The service staff is very friendly and the food is real Italian cuisine

Visited the Ristorante before going to the theater. Unfortunately the service was not commensurate with the prices. Maybe the waiter shouldn't constantly look at the door when ordering, then the right drinks would come. Pizza Quattro Stagioni with 3 ingredients? And then discuss it with the customer? Last but not least, it was shortly before the start of the theater and the bill was just placed on the table without being collected and then dishes were cleared away at other tables. A pity.

Basically a good restaurant, with good food. The prices for the food are reasonable. The wine prices are expensive relative to purchases (at least a factor of 3) The service varies greatly. If you order a bottle of wine, the service is much more attentive than if you just order a glass of wine, which sometimes leads to long waiting times.

Just fine. Almost always fully booked. We were very impressed with the food, the service and the ambience. Wasn't the last visit. Expensive but absolutely worth it.

Pasta okay, pizza very primitive, good service. Acoustically close, and if you like the theater goers walking around you..... The best thing is the friendly boss and the friendly service staff. If you want to go out for a big and expensive meal, you're in good hands there.

The food was very tasty, but the portions could have been a little larger

Very nice restaurant. We all liked it and recommend it. Only the food took a long time to arrive!

Sehr schönes Restaurant mit einer Top italienische Küche. Modernes Design aber trotzdem gemütlich . Es gibt auch einen Raucher Bereich wo man auch essen kann . Finde gut dass es auch Pizza gibt. Komme gerne wieder

Lunch is always okay, there is a reasonable selection of soup or salad in advance and prompt service.

Pasta dishes are not recommended.

Food really good. Service only responds to requests. Price performance borderline. We felt like milk cows! Very large room, with maximum seating. This means a significantly reduced ambience. You have to know what is important to you!

We were very dissatisfied. Salad was wilted and almost unseasoned, dry. The pizzas were just lukewarm and tasteless. We're not coming anymore Petra from Tübingen

What can you say? Went to La Commedia with the entire company of 38 people and had an all-round great evening. We had agreed on our meal beforehand, which wasn't a problem at all. And in the evening at our meal everything was just perfect. Service is rarely experienced at this level, everything was possible and no problem. The food was amazing, simply delicious. Dear La Commedia team, thank you for this wonderful evening 🫶 And an absolute recommendation.

Sällskap på 4 personer. Totalt smaklös mat. Antipastan hade en räka på nån skaldjursrätt(resten bläckfisk), Tomat och mossarela samt julskinka och nån typ grön röra. Efter det en ravioli utan smak och som secondi risotto som var blekare än bordduken och kalv som var helt okryddat. Summa sumarum var att det var typisk tysk mat på en italiensk restaurang. Blek och smaklös.

The price was up - the food was ok, but I've eaten better for cheaper. The parmesan pasta with truffle was very oily and too bland for me (seasoned several times) - I missed the parmesan taste. Pizza was freshly topped, large but there was still room for improvement. Service was very friendly and professional. My conclusion: You can do it.

Big Scam on the part of the waiter addition €146 In the final cost of the meal €203 56€ of tips without knowing it, no respect, a shame!!!

Very tasty and friendly service

I was there once and had an Acqua Panna and a starter soup. Both were indistinguishable in terms of taste. Staff are quite dissatisfied during lunchtime.

So the restaurant itself is really very nice and elegant… the food was also very tasty… but the waiters… they could really be a bit friendlier. That's why only 3 in total ⭐️⭐️⭐️

Food was expensive but tasty. Light a bit dark. But Danilo was a 10/10 in terms of service. Thanks danilo!

Absolute favorite Italian restaurant in Stuttgart. I went to La Commedia Stuttgart with my friends on Saturday evening. We received great service and the food was excellent. Sure - there is a lot going on at peak times and the waiting times may be a little longer than at a to-go restaurant, but it's worth it! Absolute recommendation!

I ate paccheri with beef fillet tips there the night before yesterday and can't remember the last time I had such delicious pasta. The restaurant was quite busy, but the food was on the table after 15 minutes. The service staff is professional, personable and super attentive.

Very friendly and attentive service as well as a very tasteful ambience! Not a long wait for the food, which was extremely tasty. The paccheri with seafood and the pizzas are recommended

Great Italian where no wish goes unfulfilled. Full even on weekdays, it's better to reserve if you come after 7 p.m.

Worst service in all of Stuttgart and extremely brash and unreasonable... In addition, food compatibility is completely and intentionally ignored. After our vegetarian pizzas accidentally had meat on it and we complained about it (which can always happen when something gets mixed up), we got the same pizza again after 1 minute where the meat had been picked out, only they overlooked 2 pieces. This is an absolute disgrace... After another complaint, the waiter said with a grin that it was the kitchen's fault and he couldn't do anything about it. The other half of our group had almost finished eating by the time we finally got a vegetarian pizza. When I then sought the conversation to give my criticism of this service, the waiter could no longer speak German in the middle of the conversation and switched to English, which he then couldn't speak anymore and only spoke Italian. In other words, criticism is ignored here and the guests' concerns are simply ignored. Absolutely unacceptable... What's more, of course, is that a number of negative reviews were recently deleted. This shows how criticism is handled here or not...

Super courteous and attentive service. Been there countless times and have always had excellent food. I love the Parma ham with trombinis and the pasta with clams. Every other dish tastes great too...now I feel like eating it again just because I have to think about her! The Lugana they serve there is also extremely tasty. A restaurant for every day!

Very good quality - very friendly service - level so please keep it up

Unfortunately not at all enthusiastic. For the price I would have expected more. Service was ok. Why does the operator have negative recessions deleted?

Lässt schlechte Bewertungen löschen.

Food is very tasty and service is also good. We were there on 12/27/23. Even when things are busy, we always ensure that needs are met promptly.